Apartment Hunting on a Budget in NYC? Here Are 5 Affordable Neighborhoods to Explore in Queens

The dream of living in New York City often comes with a hefty price tag, and finding an affordable apartment can feel like searching for the mythical unicorn.

The Big Apple consistently tops the lists of the most expensive cities in the U.S., and the borough of Queens is no exception. While it dishes up an amazing mix of cultures, cool communities, and easy access to Manhattan, the cost of just being here can feel like a major roadblock for many. In fact, the cost of living in Queens is 42% higher than the national average and still 13% above the rest of New York State.

Rental apartments in Queens go for an average of $3,179 as of March 2025. That’s nearly double what renters across the country typically pay (about $1,755).

But hold up! If you have your heart set on making Queens your home without emptying your savings account, this amazing borough offers some pockets of affordability worth exploring. We’ve put together a guide spotlighting the best affordable neighborhoods in Queens where you can snag a rental apartment without your wallet weeping.

• Jackson Heights
• Jamaica Hills
• Elmhurst
• Murray Hill
• Downtown Flushing

Jackson Heights

Average Rent as of March 2025: $2,645

Jackson Heights stands out as one of the best affordable neighborhoods in Queens. This culturally rich area is known for its historic architecture, bustling commercial streets, and diverse population. Renting an apartment in Jackson Heights means immersing yourself in a global community. You can find authentic cuisine from around the world and experience a unique neighborhood charm. On top of this, the area has  excellent public transportation options, making commutes to other parts of Queens and Manhattan a breeze.

Jackson Heights has lots of well-maintained pre-war apartment buildings, many with reasonable rental prices compared to other parts of the city. Renters here enjoy access to a wide array of amenities, including local shops, international markets, and a diverse culinary scene. One of the most popular local green spaces is Travers Park, a great place for recreation and community events.

Jamaica Hills

Average Rent as of March 2025: $2,469

Nestled in central Queens, Jamaica Hills offers a more suburban feel while providing budget-friendly options for New York City renters — the average rent here is $2,469. This area is characterized by its tree-lined streets, detached houses, and a quieter atmosphere compared to some of the more crowded neighborhoods closer to Manhattan. Renting in Jamaica Hills often means finding larger apartments or even small houses at more accessible prices.

Jamaica Hills renters enjoy a more peaceful living environment, good public schools, and access to local parks and green spaces. While it might not have the same level of commercial activity as some other Queens neighborhoods, it offers a strong sense of community and a more relaxed pace of life without sacrificing convenience and affordability.

Elmhurst

Average Rent as of March 2025: $2,392

With an average rent of $2,392, Elmhurst strikes a balance between affordability and convenience, making it one of the best affordable neighborhoods in this part of New York City. Located in the western part of Queens, Elmhurst boasts a diverse mix of residential buildings, busy commercial areas, and great public transit options. Renters here benefit from easy access to a wide range of shops and services along Queens Boulevard and Broadway.

Additionally, the neighborhood offers a variety of housing options, and Elmhurst Park provides a local green space for recreation. The area is known for its diverse culinary scene, reflecting the neighborhood’s multicultural population.

Murray Hill

Average Rent as of March 2025: $2,312

Often overlooked, Murray Hill — located in the Flushing area of Queens — offers renters surprising affordability with an average rent of around $2,312. This primarily residential neighborhood provides a quieter atmosphere, but is still close to the commercial hub of Flushing.

For renters, living in Murray Hill means enjoying a peaceful environment, good schools, and proximity to the amenities of Flushing. The area offers a more suburban feel compared to some other parts of Queens, making it attractive to families and those seeking a quieter lifestyle. However, it still has a diverse selection of shops and restaurants. Plus, the historic Weeping Beech Park, with its unique and ancient tree, is a popular local attraction offering a green space and playground.

Downtown Flushing

Average Rent as of March 2025: $2,203

Downtown Flushing, with an average rent of $2,203, stands out as one of the most affordable neighborhoods in Queens. This dynamic area offers a mix of residential, commercial, and cultural activities. Renters in Downtown Flushing can find a variety of apartment options at relatively affordable prices compared to the Queens average.

Living in Flushing provides unparalleled access to a wide range of amenities, including diverse restaurants, lively markets, and numerous shops. It’s also a major transportation hub, with excellent subway and bus connections to Manhattan and other parts of Queens. While it’s a busy and energetic neighborhood, it offers a unique cultural experience and a strong sense of community. The historic Bowne House — the oldest house in Queens and one of the oldest in all of New York City, dating back to 1661 — offers a glimpse into the area’s rich history.

Ready to explore these affordable neighborhoods and discover your happy place? Start your apartment search today on RentCafe.com and unlock the potential of living in this unique New York City borough! And while you’re at it, explore the best affordable neighborhoods in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and the Bronx.