5 Affordable Neighborhoods in Brooklyn for New Yorkers on a Budget

New York City has long been one of America’s most expensive rental markets, with sky-high prices that can make finding housing in affordable neighborhoods feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. In 2025, apartments in New York City remain at the top of the list for pricey housing. While the average national rent sits at $1,748 per month as of November 2024, New Yorkers often pay double or triple that amount for similar-sized apartments.

Brooklyn, once considered the more affordable alternative to Manhattan, has seen rents jump dramatically over the past decade. So, with an average rent of $3,571 across the borough, it has become increasingly challenging for renters on a budget to find apartments in Brooklyn.

Plus, the cost of living in Brooklyn is 29% higher than the state average and a jaw-dropping 62% higher than the national average, making it even harder to find apartments for rent without breaking the bank. But all hope’s not lost. Despite these high costs, Brooklyn still has pockets of affordability for those willing to look beyond the trendier areas. There are neighborhoods here that offer a genuine NYC experience without the huge price tag.

Let’s explore five of the best affordable neighborhoods in Brooklyn where you can find reasonable rents without sacrificing quality of life in this amazing slice of the Big Apple:

• Flatbush
• Borough Park
• Kensington
• Bensonhurst
• Marine Park

Flatbush: A relatively affordable neighborhood in Brooklyn

Average rent as of November 2024: $2,271

Flatbush is a relatively reasonable neighborhood where the average rent is about $2,271, well below the New York City average. This neighborhood mixes old-school charm with modern convenience like no other. You’ll find gems such as the Flatbush Library and Kings Theatre, which give the area its unmistakable local flavor, while a variety of Caribbean and Italian eateries serve up delicious flavors on every corner.

Strolling through bustling streets, renters can enjoy vibrant community markets, well-kept parks, and easy access to public transportation. With its friendly vibe and strong safety record, Flatbush stands out as one of the best neighborhoods to truly experience the heart of Brooklyn.

Borough Park: A cultural hub with reasonable rents

Average Rent as of November 2024: $2,132

Borough Park shines as one of the best picks for apartment hunters in Brooklyn, with rents averaging $2,132. The area is steeped in rich cultural traditions, featuring numerous kosher eateries, family-run bakeries, and bustling markets that give the neighborhood its unique vibe.

Local landmarks like the Borough Park Synagogue serve as community hubs, and small parks provide safe spaces for families to relax. With its close-knit community and a mix of modern and traditional amenities, Borough Park remains an accessible neighborhood that truly captures the essence of Brooklyn living.

Kensington: A laid-back, artsy pocket of affordability

Average Rent as of November 2024: $2,103

In Kensington, renters shell out roughly $2,103, on average, while soaking up a relaxed, picturesque atmosphere close to Prospect Park — but without the pricey rents. This affordable Brooklyn neighborhood features tree-lined streets, a blend of classic and modern buildings, and plenty of inviting cafes and boutique shops.

Local spots like Kensington Gardens and a lively weekend market bring a unique buzz that appeals to both art enthusiasts and foodies. With its quiet lanes, creative community projects, and friendly locals, Kensington stands out as a safe and welcoming option among Brooklyn’s best affordable neighborhoods.

Bensonhurst: The most diverse area in Brooklyn

Average Rent as of November 2024: $1,914

Bensonhurst is among the more affordable neighborhoods in Brooklyn, with an average rent of about $1,914. Celebrated for its rich cultural diversity, it offers a range of dining options — from traditional Italian spots to modern fusion restaurants — and strong community ties. Once known as Brooklyn’s “Little Italy” with an 80% Italian population in the 1980s, it now boasts the largest number of residents born in China and Hong Kong of any NYC neighborhood.

Bensonhurst is often described as a quiet, walkable, and relatively affordable neighborhood to other Brooklyn areas, making it popular with professionals, families with children, and retirees. With highlights like Bensonhurst Park and local art galleries, this area offers safe streets and a strong community spirit for renters on a budget.

Marine Park: A peaceful, budget-friendly spot by the water

Average Rent as of November 2024: $1,884

Marine Park stands out as one of Brooklyn’s most affordable neighborhoods, where apartments rent for $1,884, on average. But it’s more than just a bargain — Marine Park is cherished by locals for its sprawling green spaces and soothing waterfront views that offer a break from New York City’s constant buzz. On warm days, you’ll see residents jogging along winding paths, families enjoying impromptu picnics on sunlit lawns, and neighbors gathering for spontaneous outdoor meetups.

The streets here have a well-tended, homey feel, where friendly faces are common, and community spirit is alive in every corner. Locals love taking leisurely strolls along tree-lined avenues and stopping by small neighborhood spots that reflect the true character of Brooklyn. Marine Park perfectly blends the convenience of city living with a touch of suburban calm. This makes it one of the best affordable neighborhoods in Brooklyn for those who want a slice of genuine local life.

If you’re a renter looking to stretch your dollars without compromising on quality of life, Brooklyn’s affordable neighborhoods have a lot to offer. Each spot comes with its own unique character, local vibe, and tight-knit community, proving that you don’t have to break the bank to experience the best of Brooklyn living. Now’s the time to dive deeper into these affordable Brooklyn gems and find the neighborhood that speaks to you.

Looking for apartments in other places around the country? Check out our guides for the best affordable neighborhoods in Seattle; Grand Rapids, MI; Austin, TX; San Antonio, TX; Detroit; Chicago; Atlanta; Denver; Miami; Minneapolis; Reno, NV; Columbus, OH; Hialeah, FL; Fayetteville, NC; Salt Lake City; Washington, DC; Knoxville, TN; and St. Paul, MN.