Apartments for Rent in Middle Island, NY

Prices and availability in Middle Island, NY were last updated on 15 May 2026.

The best apartments in Middle Island, NY are: Stonegate, Eagle View Court 55+ Community and 9 Fairview Cir, Unit 2.

The average rent in Middle Island, NY is $2,621.

The price range for a 1-bedroom apartment in Middle Island, NY is between $2,641 and $2,899.

The price range for a 2-bedroom apartment in Middle Island, NY is between $2,500 and $3,487.

The price range for a 3-bedroom apartment in Middle Island, NY is between $3,724 and $3,938.

In Middle Island 31% of the housing is rented out compared to 69% of homes are owned, according to the most recent Census Bureau estimates. 15% of Middle Island's apartments are found in large buildings of 50 units or more, 72% are located in smaller apartment complexes with less than 50 units, and 13% are single-family rentals.

The average age of rental buildings in Middle Island is 34 years old, with 32% being newer apartment buildings completed since 2000. The average height of apartment buildings in the city is 2 stories, of which all are garden-style apartment communities, none are mid-sized buildings, and none are high-rises. These characteristics describe large-scale apartment communities of 50 apartments or more.

Rental apartments in Middle Island come in a range of sizes and floorplans. Studio apartments represent 0% of units for rent, ideal for singles, renters on a budget and people who value central locations more than space. Rentals with 1-bedroom floorplans make up 39% of the total apartments in the city, while 2-bedroom floorplans represent around 56% of all rentals in Middle Island. The rest are larger floorplans with 3 bedrooms or more, typically preferred by families, larger households or roommates sharing space.