Amherst, NY Rental Market Trends
What is the average rent in Amherst?
The average rent for an apartment in Amherst is $1,822. The cost of rent varies depending on several factors, including location, size, and quality.
Average rent in Amherst, NY
Average Rent | Average Apartment Size |
---|---|
$1,822 | 992 sq. ft. |
What is the average apartment size in Amherst?
The average size for a Amherst, NY apartment is 992 square feet, but this number varies greatly depending on unit type, with cheap and luxury alternatives for houses and apartments alike. Studio apartments are the smallest and most affordable, 1-bedroom apartments are closer to the average, while 2-bedroom apartments and 3-bedroom apartments offer a more generous square footage.
Amherst, NY apartment rent ranges
Amherst, NY Occupied Housing Units
12,727 or 31% of the households in Amherst, NY are renter-occupied while 28,593 or 69% are owner-occupied.
Amherst, NY rent trends

Average Rent in Amherst, NY By Neighborhood
City | Average Rent |
---|---|
Harris Hill | $2,293 |
Clarence Town | $2,125 |
Williamsville | $1,797 |
Amherst Town | $1,791 |
Lancaster | $1,685 |
Orchard Park | $1,434 |
Grand Island Town | $1,403 |
Hamburg Town | $1,393 |
West Seneca | $1,366 |
Buffalo | $1,365 |
Cheektowaga Town | $1,363 |
Tonawanda Town | $1,228 |
Kenmore | $1,011 |
What are the most affordable neighborhoods in Amherst?
The most affordable neighborhoods in Amherst are Kenmore, where the average rent goes for $1,011/month, Tonawanda Town, where renters pay $1,228/mo on average, and Cheektowaga Town, where the average rent goes for $1,363/mo. If you’re looking for other great deals, check out the listings from Buffalo ($1,365), West Seneca ($1,366), and Hamburg Town ($1,393), where the asking prices are below the average Amherst rent of $1,822/mo.
What are the most expensive neighborhoods in Amherst?
The most expensive neighborhoods in Amherst are Williamsville ($1,797), Clarence Town ($2,125) and Harris Hill ($2,293).
What are the most popular neighborhoods in Amherst?
The most popular neighborhood in Amherst is Buffalo, where there are 55 listings with an average rent of $1,365. Next up is Amherst Town, where apartments go for $1,791/month, followed by Tonawanda Town with $1,228 If you’re looking to rent in Amherst’s most popular neighborhoods, make sure to also check out Cheektowaga Town, where renters pay $1,363 on average, and Lancaster, where the average monthly rent is $1,685.
Amherst | Rent Comparison by Neighborhood
Rent in Amherst Town is 31% higher than in Buffalo
Amherst Town rent is 2% lower than Amherst average
Buffalo rent is 25% lower than Amherst average
How Amherst Compares to Other Cities
State | Average Rent |
---|---|
New York City | $4,705 |
Manhattan | $5,117 |
Hudson Valley | $2,494 |
Brooklyn | $3,695 |
Queens | $3,161 |
Buffalo | $1,365 |
Ithaca | $2,255 |
Amherst Town | $1,791 |
Albany | $1,681 |
Amherst | $1,822 |
Tonawanda Town | $1,228 |
Amityville | $2,850 |
White Plains | $3,261 |
Cheektowaga Town | $1,363 |
Lancaster | $1,685 |
Hamburg Town | $1,393 |
Orchard Park | $1,434 |
Grand Island Town | $1,403 |