Save Search

Apartments for Rent in Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL

Quick filters

  • More Rentals Near Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL

  • Rent specials New Units Available
    1 bd $1,258+
    2 bd $1,763+
    3 bd $2,028+
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    MAA Fleming Island

    4.5 (56)
    2285 Marsh Hawk Lane, Fleming Island, FL 32003
    Apply online • Pet friendly • Fitness center
  • Only 1 unit left
    3 bd $2,145
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    2878 Woodstone Dr Middleburg, FL 32068

    2878 Woodstone Dr, Middleburg, FL 32068
    Apply online • Pet friendly • Dishwasher
  • Only 1 unit left
    Studio $1,950
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    1512 PAWNEE DRIVE

    1512 PAWNEE ST., ORANGE PARK, FL 32065
    Apply online • Pet friendly
  • Only 2 units left
    1 bd $1,140+
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    Jefferson Way

    5.0 (4)
    409 Jefferson Ave, Orange Park, FL 32065
    Apply online • Pet friendly • In unit laundry
  • Rent specials New Units Available
    1 bd $1,338+
    2 bd $1,367+
    3 bd $1,642+
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    Cypress Pointe

    4.5 (25)
    25 Knight Boxx Road, Orange Park, FL 32065
    Apply online • Pet friendly • Pool
  • Rent specials
    1 bd $1,350
    2 bd $1,450
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    Flats At Maverick Trails

    5.0 (5)
    3045 Glen Park Lane, Orange Park, FL 32065
    Apply online • Pet friendly • Fitness center
  • 2 bd $1,375
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    Maverick Trails Townhomes

    4.5 (12)
    3045 Glen Park Lane, Orange Park, FL 32065
    Apply online • Pet friendly • Fitness center
  • Rent specials New Units Available
    1 bd $799
    2 bd $899
    3 bd $999
    Base rent Income restricted
    Verified Listing

    Hunters Run

    1535 Blanding Blvd., Middleburg, FL 32068
    Patio/Balcony • Washer/Dryer
  • Rent specials New Units Available
    1 bd $1,104+
    2 bd $1,249+
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    Arbors At Orange Park

    4.0 (9)
    198 Arora Boulevard, Orange Park, FL 32073
    Apply online • Pet friendly • Fitness center
  • Only 1 unit left
    3 bd $1,730
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    1746 Cinnamon Drive Orange Park, FL 32073

    5.0 (1)
    1746 Cinnamon Drive, Orange Park, FL 32073
    Apply online • Pet friendly • Dishwasher
  • Only 1 unit left
    2 bd $1,150
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    803 Meadowbrook Dr

    803 Meadowbrook Dr, Orange Park, FL 32073
    Apply online • Pet friendly
  • Only 1 unit left
    3 bd $1,790
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    1010 ANNA AVENUE ORANGE PARK, FL 32073

    1010 ANNA AVENUE, ORANGE PARK, FL 32073
    Apply online • Pet friendly • Dishwasher
  • 1 bd $1,111
    2 bd $1,346
    3 bd $1,564
    Base rent Income restricted
    Verified Listing

    Bryce Landing

    4.5 (32)
    1914 Bryce Landing Way, Middleburg, FL 32068
    Apply online • Pet friendly • Fitness center
  • Ask for pricing
    Verified Listing

    4689 US 17

    4689 US 17, Fleming Island, FL 32003
    Pet friendly
  • Studio $1,067
    1 bd $1,142
    2 bd $1,376
    Base rent Income restricted
    Verified Listing

    Cassie Gardens Apartments

    5.0 (11)
    534 College Drive, Middleburg, FL 32068
    Pet friendly • Fitness center
  • Ask for pricing
    Verified Listing

    1810 Dartmouth Dr

    5.0 (2)
    1810 Dartmouth Dr, Middleburg, FL 32068
    Pet friendly
  • Studio $650
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    2779 WINCHESTER AVENUE

    2779 WINCHESTER AVENUE, JACKONVILLE, FL 32065
    Pet friendly
  • Studio $1,100
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    2261 GEORGE WHYTHE ROAD

    2261 GEORGE WHYTHE ROAD, ORANGE PARK, FL 32073
    Pet friendly
  • Ask for pricing
    Income restricted
    Verified Listing

    Middletowne Apartments

    4.5 (3)
    1809 Debarry Avenue, Orange Park, FL 32073
    Pet friendly • In unit laundry • Dishwasher
  • Rent specials
    1 bd $1,083
    2 bd $1,314
    Base rent Income restricted
    Verified Listing

    Macie Creek Apartments

    4.5 (16)
    3525 Macie Loop, Middleburg, FL 32068
    Pet friendly • Fitness center
  • Studio $1,007
    Base rent Income restricted
    Verified Listing

    Molly Crossing Apartments

    5.0 (2)
    3338 Old Jennings Road, Middleburg, FL 32068
    Pet friendly • Fitness center • High Speed Internet
  • New listing
    3 bd $1,595
    Base rent
    Verified Listing

    514 W Clermont Dr

    514 W Clermont Dr, Orange Park, FL 32073
    Pet friendly • Washer/Dryer
  • 1-24-nhood

Frequently asked questions

When were prices and availability in Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL last updated?

Prices and availability in Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL were last updated on 4 Sep 2026.

What are the best apartments in Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL?

The best apartment in Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL is: 2132 PEBBLE CREEK LANE FLEMING ISLAND, FL 32003.

What is the average rent in Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL?

The average rent in Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL is $1,726.

What type of rental buildings are in Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL?

In Bay Harbor, 14% of the residents are renting compared to 86% owning a home, according to data from the U.S. Census Bureau. Large-scale apartment buildings with more than 50 units represent 10% of Bay Harbor's rentals, 65% are small-scale complexes with under 50 units, and 25% are single-family rentals.

RentCafe is your one-stop shop for finding a great new apartment in Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL. Easily search through a wide selection of apartments for rent in Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL, and view detailed information about available rentals including floor plans, pricing, photos, amenities, interactive maps, and thorough property descriptions. Property owners and managers are one click away, so feel free to contact them and find out all you need to know about the apartment you're interested in. Browse Bay Harbor, Fleming Island, FL apartments with rents starting from $650 and submit your rental application today!