Save This Search

Cheap Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

75 Rentals Available
Cheap Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY. 75 Rentals Available
Apartments Under $1,200 Apartments Under $2,000 Apartments Under $2,200 Apartments Under $2,400 Apartments Under $2,600 Apartments Under $3,000

Apartments Under $1,200

  • A park with a grassy area and trees with autumn leaves.
    Today

    10 Station Drive, Wyandanch, NY 11798
    Income Restricted
    STUDIO Ask for Pricing
    1 BED $1,012+
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing

Apartments Under $2,000

  • 25
    Top Rated for Location
    Exterior view of the Laundry Room at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706 Bathroom with a toilet and a tub and a sink at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706
    4.5
    Today

    99 South Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Available
    STUDIO $1,896
    1 BED $2,261
    2 BEDS $2,751
    Exterior view of the Laundry Room at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706 Bathroom with a toilet and a tub and a sink at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706 Building Exteriors at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706 Bedroom at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Property reviews
    4.5/5 Bayshore on Jun 6, 2025

    I have been living in Bayshore Apartment complex for over 10 years. It is quiet, will maintained, cozy place. I definitely will recommend it to anyone with small family.

    4.5/5 Anonymous on May 2, 2022

    Clean....quiet...resident services excellent

  • A kitchen with white cabinets and a black stove top oven.
    3 days ago

    25 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    1 BED $1,900

Apartments Under $2,200

  • a small kitchen with a sink and a dishwasher
    23
    Today

    100 Patricia Court, Oakdale, NY 11769
    1 BED $2,030+
  • a kitchen with a stove and a sink and a window
    17
    Today

    29 Buffalo Avenue, Islip, NY 11751
    1 BED $2,190
    2 BEDS $2,737+

Apartments Under $2,400

  • a living room with a couch and a television
    38
    Today

    500 Peconic St, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
    STUDIO $2,211+
    1 BED $2,201+
    2 BEDS $2,967+
  • a yellow house with a white balcony on top of it
    8
    Today

    Flurry Lane, West Babylon, NY 11704
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • a living room with couches and chairs and a television
    11
    Today

    143 4Th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    STUDIO $2,384+
    1 BED $2,310
    2 BEDS $4,548+

Apartments Under $2,600

Apartments Under $3,000

  • a spacious living room with white walls and a beige carpet
    16
    Today

    Grace Lane, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    2 BEDS $2,850
  • A kitchen with a white fridge and a white oven.
    3 days ago

    471 Smith Street, Central Islip, NY 11722
    2 BEDS $3,000
  • Sophia Court 2 Beds Apartment for Rent
    Today

    Sophia Court, West Babylon, NY 11704
    2 BEDS $3,000+
  • A living room with a white couch and a coffee table.
    9
    Today

    Ashley Court, North Babylon, NY 11703
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • a large house with a balcony and a street light
    Today

    Jacqueline Way, North Babylon, NY 11703
    2 BEDS $3,200

  • More Rentals Near Bay Shore, NY

  • A kitchen with white cabinets and appliances.
    6
    Today

    Nicks Way (843 Lake Blvd.), Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    2 BEDS $3,400
  • A spacious kitchen with wooden flooring and white cabinetry.
    3 days ago

    54 Evergreen St, West Babylon, NY 11704
    4 BEDS $4,200
  • Renting has its Rewards
    Start earning points to redeem on travel, experiences, gift cards, live events, and more!
    Earn points for:
    Internet and Entertainment
    Utilities
    Insurance
    Learn more
  • A living room with a fireplace and a painting above it.
    3 days ago

    338 38Th Street, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    4 BEDS $4,360
  • A living room with a fireplace and a painting above it.
    3 days ago

    338 38Th Street, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    4 BEDS $4,360
  • A large, modern living room with a dark rug and a large chandelier.
    1 day ago

    1721 Motor Pkwy, Hauppauge, NY 11788
    1 BED Ask for Pricing
    2 BEDS $4,475+
    3 BEDS $5,885+
  • a living room with a couch and a table
    1 day ago

    200 Sutton Landing Court, Commack, NY 11725
    2 BEDS $6,300+
  • a white kitchen with stainless steel appliances and white cabinets
    6
    Today

    580-594 W. Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • a sign in front of a fence
    Today

    515 Jackson Avenue, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • Interactive banner rent
    What is your max rent budget?
  • 100 Schmeelk Place 2 Beds Apartment for Rent
    Today

    100 Schmeelk Place, Copiague, NY 11726
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • an empty intersection with a shopping center and a parking lot
    Today

    6333 JERICHO TURNPIKE, COMMACK, NY 11725
    STUDIO Ask for Pricing
4-21-city
Nice work, you've checked out every rental here! Expand your search to find your happy place.

Save Search

Getting around in Bay Shore, NY

72 /100
Very Walkable
63 /100
Bikeable
Walk Score®: 72, Bike Score®: 63

Frequently asked questions

What are the advantages of renting a cheap apartment in Bay Shore, NY?

Cheap apartments in Bay Shore, NY are usually less expensive, smaller, and easier to maintain. They also come with lower utility costs.

What are the downsides of renting a cheap apartment in Bay Shore, NY?

A cheap apartment in Bay Shore, NY offers little storage space and fewer amenities compared to other apartments.

Look for cheap apartments near me

Finding the right apartment as far as size and location go is one aspect of apartment searching, but making sure that it provides all that you need within a reasonable price is another. On RentCafe, you can search for cheap apartments near you and ensure that you find one that suites your needs. Worried the neighborhood or city you are looking to move to is known to have higher rents? You can browse our listings and find the cheap apartments in any location, whether you are looking at a specific neighborhood, ZIP code, or city.

The perfect apartment for you is out there, either near you or anywhere in the U.S. that you are looking to move to. So, let's find the one that satisfies your wants and needs, but that also comes at an affordable price.

Looking for a cheap apartment for rent in Bay Shore, NY? With RentCafe, finding an affordable apartment in Bay Shore, NY has never been easier. We feature 75 low-priced rentals directly from property managers, with rents lower than the Bay Shore, NY average. What is a cheap rent in Bay Shore, NY? The average apartment rent in Bay Shore is $2,399 per month so any rental south of $1,919 would be considered cheap here. On RentCafe, Bay Shore, NY rents go as low as $1,012/mo.

Finding a home nearby is easier than you think. Check out our Apartments Near Me page and take your pick!