Gary, IN Rental Market Trends
What is the average rent in Gary?
The average rent for an apartment in Gary is $884. The cost of rent varies depending on several factors, including location, size, and quality.
Average rent in Gary, IN
Average Rent | Average Apartment Size |
---|---|
$884 | 747 sq. ft. |
What is the average apartment size in Gary?
The average size for a Gary, IN apartment is 747 square feet, but this number varies greatly depending on unit type, with cheap and luxury alternatives for houses and apartments alike. Studio apartments are the smallest and most affordable, 1-bedroom apartments are closer to the average, while 2-bedroom apartments and 3-bedroom apartments offer a more generous square footage.
Gary, IN apartment rent ranges
Gary, IN Occupied Housing Units
14,138 or 51% of the households in Gary, IN are renter-occupied while 13,635 or 49% are owner-occupied.
Gary, IN rent trends

Average Rent in Gary, IN By Neighborhood
Neighborhood | Average Rent |
---|---|
Downtown Gary | $1,701 |
Emerson | $1,701 |
Pulaski | $1,180 |
Gary - Chicago Airport | $1,071 |
Aetna | $893 |
Miller | $893 |
University Park | $840 |
Ambridge Mann | $799 |
Tolleston | $799 |
Midtown Gary | $779 |
Black Oak | $777 |
Brunswick | $715 |
West Side Gary | $715 |
What are the most affordable neighborhoods in Gary?
The most affordable neighborhoods in Gary are Brunswick, where the average rent goes for $715/month, West Side Gary, where renters pay $715/mo on average, and Black Oak, where the average rent goes for $777/mo. If you’re looking for other great deals, check out the listings from Midtown Gary ($779), Ambridge Mann ($799), and Tolleston ($799), where the asking prices are below the average Gary rent of $884/mo.
What are the most expensive neighborhoods in Gary?
The most expensive neighborhoods in Gary are Pulaski ($1,180), Downtown Gary ($1,701) and Emerson ($1,701).
What are the most popular neighborhoods in Gary?
The most popular neighborhood in Gary is Tolleston, where there are 1 listings with an average rent of $799. Next up is West Side Gary, where apartments go for $715/month, followed by Aetna with $893 If you’re looking to rent in Gary’s most popular neighborhoods, make sure to also check out Ambridge Mann, where renters pay $799 on average, and Black Oak, where the average monthly rent is $777.
Gary | Rent Comparison by Neighborhood
Rent in Aetna is 12% higher than in Ambridge Mann
Aetna rent is 1% higher than Gary average
Average Rent | $893 |
---|
Ambridge Mann rent is 10% lower than Gary average
Average Rent | $799 |
---|
How Gary Compares to Other Cities
City | Average Rent |
---|---|
Chicago | $2,309 |
Indianapolis | $1,191 |
Oak Park | $2,118 |
Evanston | $2,295 |
New Albany | $1,050 |
Bloomington | $1,445 |
Greenwood | $1,231 |
Jeffersonville | $1,147 |
Lafayette | $1,003 |
Fort Wayne | $1,099 |
Lawrence | $1,056 |
South Bend | $1,205 |
Carmel | $1,653 |
Naperville | $1,904 |
Lansing | $1,137 |
Merrillville | $1,303 |
Riverdale | $940 |
Arlington Heights | $1,875 |
Hammond | $1,084 |
Valparaiso | $1,277 |
Gary | $884 |
What is the average price for a storage unit in Gary?
The average rent for a non-climate-controlled 10'x10' storage unit in Gary is $129. Rental costs vary depending on several factors, including unit size and the storage facility's location and amenities.