Save This Search

Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

78 Rentals Available
  • 24
    Top Rated for Location
    Exterior view of the Laundry Room at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706 Bathroom with a toilet and a tub and a sink at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706
    4.5
    Today

    99 South Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Available
    STUDIO $1,896
    1 BED $2,121
    2 BEDS $2,751
    Exterior view of the Laundry Room at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706 Bathroom with a toilet and a tub and a sink at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706 Building Exteriors at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706 Bedroom at Brookwood at Bay Shore in Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Property reviews
    4.5/5 Bayshore on Jun 6, 2025

    I have been living in Bayshore Apartment complex for over 10 years. It is quiet, will maintained, cozy place. I definitely will recommend it to anyone with small family.

    4.5/5 Anonymous on May 2, 2022

    Clean....quiet...resident services excellent

  • an architectural rendering of a large white house on a street
    Today

    6 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    STUDIO $2,200
    1 BED $3,000
  • a living room with couches and chairs and a television
    11
    Today

    143 4Th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    STUDIO $2,388+
    1 BED $2,310
    2 BEDS $2,570
  • A kitchen with a stove top oven and a tile floor.
    Today

    1077 Martinstein Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    2 BEDS $2,300
  • A living room with a grey couch and a television.
    Today

    1425 Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    2 BEDS $2,400
  • A kitchen with white cabinets and a black stove top oven.
    Today

    25 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    1 BED $1,900
  • Renting has its Rewards
    Start earning points to redeem on travel, experiences, gift cards, live events, and more!
    Earn points for:
    Internet and Entertainment
    Utilities
    Insurance
    Learn more

  • More Rentals Near Bay Shore, NY

  • a kitchen with a stove and a sink and a window
    17
    Today

    29 Buffalo Avenue, Islip, NY 11751
    1 BED $2,190
    2 BEDS $2,737+
  • a small kitchen with a sink and a dishwasher
    23
    Today

    100 Patricia Court, Oakdale, NY 11769
    1 BED $2,030+
  • a living room with a couch and a television
    38
    Today

    500 Peconic St, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
    STUDIO $2,191+
    1 BED $2,181+
    2 BEDS $3,037+
  • a kitchen with white cabinets and a stove and a microwave
    18
    Today

    168 Oakdale-Bohemia Road, Bohemia, NY 11716
    STUDIO $2,441+
    1 BED $2,416+
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • A living room with a white couch and a coffee table.
    9
    Today

    Ashley Court, North Babylon, NY 11703
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • a large house with a balcony and a street light
    Today

    Jacqueline Way, North Babylon, NY 11703
    2 BEDS $3,200
  • Interactive banner rent
    What is your max rent budget?
  • A spacious kitchen with wooden flooring and white cabinetry.
    Today

    54 Evergreen St, West Babylon, NY 11704
    4 BEDS $4,400
  • A kitchen with a white fridge and a white oven.
    Today

    471 Smith Street, Central Islip, NY 11722
    2 BEDS $3,000
  • a yellow house with a white balcony on top of it
    8
    Today

    Flurry Lane, West Babylon, NY 11704
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • Sophia Court 2 Beds Apartment for Rent
    Today

    Sophia Court, West Babylon, NY 11704
    2 BEDS $3,000+
  • A park with a grassy area and trees with autumn leaves.
    Today

    10 Station Drive, Wyandanch, NY 11798
    Income Restricted
    STUDIO Ask for Pricing
    1 BED $1,012+
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • a spacious living room with white walls and a beige carpet
    16
    Today

    Grace Lane, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    2 BEDS $2,850
  • Interactive banner bedroom
    How many bedrooms are you
    looking for?
  • A kitchen with white cabinets and appliances.
    6
    Today

    Nicks Way (843 Lake Blvd.), Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    2 BEDS $3,400
  • a white kitchen with stainless steel appliances and white cabinets
    6
    Today

    580-594 W. Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • A living room with a fireplace and a painting above it.
    Today

    338 38Th Street, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    4 BEDS $4,360
  • A living room with a fireplace and a painting above it.
    Today

    338 38Th Street, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    4 BEDS $4,360
  • a sign in front of a fence
    Today

    515 Jackson Avenue, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • A large, modern living room with a dark rug and a large chandelier.
    Today

    1721 Motor Pkwy, Hauppauge, NY 11788
    1 BED Ask for Pricing
    2 BEDS $4,475+
    3 BEDS $5,885+
  • a living room with a couch and a table
    Today

    200 Sutton Landing Court, Commack, NY 11725
    2 BEDS $6,300+
6-19-city
Nice work, you've checked out every rental here! Expand your search to find your happy place.

Save Search

Bay Shore, NY rent trends

Rental prices in Bay Shore, NY have increased by 7.81% over the past year. The average rent moved from $2,225 to $2,399.

Check out the average rent prices in Bay Shore by neighborhood.

Compared to the national average rent of $1,750, the average rent in Bay Shore, NY is $2,399.

Average rent in Bay Shore, NY

$2,399/mo Bay Shore, NY average rental price, September 2025
Image Average Rent

The average monthly rent of apartments in Bay Shore, NY is $2,399.

    What's the typical rent budget in Bay Shore, NY?

    About 31% of apartment rents in Bay Shore, NY range between $2,501-$3,000. Meanwhile, apartments around > $3,000 represent 10% of apartments. Around 37% of Bay Shore’s apartments are in the $2,001-$2,500 price range. 21% of apartments are priced between $1,501-$2,000.

    The largest share of rentals in Bay Shore, NY (37%) fall between $2,001-$2,500 per month. This suggests that most people succesfully find suitable apartments within this price.

    Getting around in Bay Shore, NY

    72 /100
    Very Walkable
    63 /100
    Bikeable
    Walk Score®: 72, Bike Score®: 63

    Frequently asked questions

    When were prices and availability in Bay Shore, NY last updated?

    Prices and availability in Bay Shore, NY were last updated on 18 Nov 2025.

    What are the best apartments in Bay Shore, NY?

    The best apartments in Bay Shore, NY are: Brookwood at Bay Shore, Lofts on Ocean, Shoregate, 1077 Martinstein Avenue and 1425 Penataquit Avenue, Unit 1.

    What is the average rent in Bay Shore, NY?

    The average rent in Bay Shore, NY is $2,284.

    What is the price range for a studio apartment in Bay Shore, NY?

    The price range for a studio apartment in Bay Shore, NY is between $1,896 and $5,518.

    What is the price range for a 1-bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY?

    The price range for a 1-bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY is between $1,900 and $6,128.

    What is the price range for a 2-bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY?

    The price range for a 2-bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY is between $2,300 and $6,700.

    What is the price range for a 3-bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY?

    The price range for a 3-bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY is between $2,388 and $6,700.

    What type of rental buildings are in Bay Shore, NY?

    In Bay Shore, 38% of the residents are renting compared to 62% owning a home, according to data from the U.S. Census Bureau. Large-scale apartment buildings with more than 50 units represent 22% of Bay Shore’s rentals, 61% are small-scale complexes with under 50 units, and 16% are single-family rentals.

    What do typical apartment communities look like in Bay Shore, NY?

    The age and size of multifamily buildings are among the most visible characteristics of the rental market in a city.  In this case, the apartment buildings in Bay Shore are about 49 years old, on average. Of these, 10% have been built since 2000, representing the newer options on the market and typically offering more amenities. Rental buildings in the city have an average height of 3 stories. About 90% of the rental communities here are low-rise, garden-style communities, 10% are mid-rises, and none are high-rise buildings. These are true especially for large-scale multifamily buildings with over 50 apartments.

    What apartment floorplans are common in Bay Shore, NY?

    Studio apartments in Bay Shore are around 4% of rentals, while 1-bedroom floor plans represent 64% of the total stock. For those in search of larger rentals, 2-bedroom floorplans make up 30% of all rentals. More generous apartments with 3 bedrooms or more are also available in this city for those in search of more space.

    Living in Bay Shore, NY

    Bay Shore, NY, is a small hamlet that is technically part of the town of Islip on Long Island. It’s located on the south shore of the area on the Great South Bay. As a coastal town in an area that is so close to New York City, many renters live here to commute to Manhattan for work. A suburb of New York City, the town of Bay Shore is lined with shops, restaurants, coffee houses and bars, making it an ideal place to live for renters who like a dense, suburban area with amenities around every corner. In particular, Benjamin’s Memorial Beach is a great place for renters to spend the day frolicking in the water and sun-tanning on the beach. For renters who have families, the school system run by Bay Shore Union Free School District is very highly rated. Overall, living in Bay Shore provides renters with close proximity to “the City” (NYC), as well as a close-knit atmosphere of friendly neighbors in a classic New York neighborhood.

    Renting in Bay Shore, NY

    There are plenty of waterfront rental apartments and coastal townhomes that make renting in Bay Shore a popular place. Rental apartments range from smaller buildings to larger high-rises overlooking the bay. Most have unique amenities, such as dry cleaning service, business centers, indoor pools and 24-hour fitness centers. Of course, all of the apartment complexes are trying to cater to the busy professional who commutes every day into New York City. A nice part of living in Bay Shore is that there are walkable places all around the community for renters to visit, such as bars, convenience stores and small shops.

    Things for renting

    Shopping in Bay Shore, NY

    There’s an abundance of great shopping all around Long Island, including locations in Bay Shore. For instance, Westfield South Shore is a big indoor mall with around 100 stores, including JCPenney and Macy’s, as well as a food court right off of Sunrise Highway. There are also other shopping plazas that renters frequent that are more like strip malls around town, including Bay Shore Commons and the Market at Bay Shore. Each will have banks, salons and a grocery store as its anchor near rental apartments. Grocery shopping is also convenient for renters all around Bay Shore with places like Whole Foods Market; ShopRite of Bay Shore; and Stop & Shop with produce, prepared foods and specialty items.

    Transportation in Bay Shore, NY

    One of the best parts of living in Bay Shore is the excellent public transportation run by Suffolk County Transit. For example, there are many buses that go throughout the town near rental apartments with connections into Manhattan and other parts of New York City, like Queens, the Bronx and Brooklyn. The Long Island Railroad also has a stop in Bay Shore that goes into the city, making a daily commute for renters who work there a breeze. Notably, most renters won’t take a car into the city and will choose to use daily public transportation. Finally, the closest airport for renters is right in town: The Long Island MacArthur Airport is a small airport in Islip with daily connections to lots of major cities around the United States. It’s only 12 miles away from Bay Shore via NY 27 West.

    Look for apartments near me

    Are you looking to land that one apartment near you that ticks all the boxes? Now you can browse through available RentCafe apartment listings in your area, rated and reviewed by verified residents. Comparing the size, price, amenities and location of apartments for rent near you is easier than ever. Do you feel like expanding the search beyond your neighborhood and ZIP code? Browse apartments for rent in your city and state to find the best fit, wherever you are in the U.S. Somewhere out there is the perfect apartment just waiting for you.

    Whether you're looking for a studio, an apartment with one or more bedrooms, or maybe you're upgrading to a luxury apartment or need to acommodate a pet, RentCafe allows you to easily search for a rental near you based on your criteria, anywhere in the U.S. So, let's find your new home today!

    RentCafe is your one-stop shop for finding a great new apartment in Bay Shore, NY. Easily search through a wide selection of apartments for rent in Bay Shore, NY, and view detailed information about available rentals including floor plans, pricing, photos, amenities, interactive maps, and thorough property descriptions. Property owners and managers are one click away, so feel free to contact them and find out all you need to know about the apartment you’re interested in. Browse Bay Shore, NY apartments with rents starting from $1,012 and submit your rental application today!

    Finding a home nearby is easier than you think. Check out our Apartments Near Me page and take your pick!