Apartments for Rent in Fayetteville, NY

Prices and availability in Fayetteville, NY were last updated on 15 Oct 2026.

The best apartments in Fayetteville, NY are: 104 Edgemere Ln, Unit 23 and 107 Margo Ln.

The average rent in Fayetteville, NY is $1,419.

In Fayetteville, 23% of the residents are renting compared to 77% owning a home, according to data from the U.S. Census Bureau. Large-scale apartment buildings with more than 50 units represent 4% of Fayetteville's rentals, 83% are small-scale complexes with under 50 units, and 13% are single-family rentals.

The age and size of multifamily buildings are among the most visible characteristics of the rental market in a city. In this case, the apartment buildings in Fayetteville are about 50 years old, on average. Of these, none have been built since 2000, representing the newer options on the market and typically offering more amenities. Rental buildings in the city have an average height of 3 stories. About all of the rental communities here are low-rise, garden-style communities, none are mid-rises, and none are high-rise buildings. These are true especially for large-scale multifamily buildings with over 50 apartments.

Rental apartments in Fayetteville come in a range of sizes and floorplans. Studio apartments represent 0% of units for rent, ideal for singles, renters on a budget and people who value central locations more than space. Rentals with 1-bedroom floorplans make up 32% of the total apartments in the city, while 2-bedroom floorplans represent around 58% of all rentals in Fayetteville. The rest are larger floorplans with 3 bedrooms or more, typically preferred by families, larger households or roommates sharing space.