Apartments for rent – RentCafe
Contact this property now:

Extra Space Storage - 1249 Coney Island Avenue, Brooklyn, NY

Self Storage 20 - 260 Sq. Ft.
4.8/5 - 462 Reviews
Location:
1249 Coney Island Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11230
24/7 ACCESS
All units
Small
Medium
Large
Loading... Loading results...
Units Availability
Small Storage Unit
15x6
Self Storage
90 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$299/mo
Small Storage Unit
10x9
Self Storage
90 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$299/mo
Small Storage Unit
10x8
Self Storage
80 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$299/mo
Small Storage Unit
10x7
Self Storage
70 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$268/mo
Small Storage Unit
10x5
Self Storage
50 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$289/mo
Small Storage Unit
10x5
Self Storage
50 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$200/mo
Small Storage Unit
10x4
Self Storage
40 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$166/mo
Small Storage Unit
9x5
Self Storage
45 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$184/mo
Small Storage Unit
8x12
Self Storage
96 Sq. Ft.
$334/mo
Small Storage Unit
8x10
Self Storage
80 Sq. Ft.
$334/mo
Small Storage Unit
8x10
Self Storage
80 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$299/mo
Small Storage Unit
8x9
Self Storage
72 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$275/mo
Small Storage Unit
8x5
Self Storage
40 Sq. Ft.
$190/mo
Small Storage Unit
7x10
Self Storage
70 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$268/mo
Small Storage Unit
7x5
Self Storage
35 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$149/mo
Small Storage Unit
6x4
Self Storage
24 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$111/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x15
Self Storage
75 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$287/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x11
Self Storage
55 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$216/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x10
Self Storage
50 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$200/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x9
Self Storage
45 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$184/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x8
Self Storage
40 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$166/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x7
Self Storage
35 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$149/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x6
Self Storage
30 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$133/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x5
Self Storage
25 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$31 - $167/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x5
Self Storage
25 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$30 - $114/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x4
Self Storage
20 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$96/mo
Medium Storage Unit
15x11
Self Storage
165 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$513/mo
Medium Storage Unit
15x10
Self Storage
150 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$473/mo
Medium Storage Unit
13x9
Self Storage
117 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$372/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x15
Self Storage
150 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$473/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x13
Self Storage
130 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$527/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x12
Self Storage
120 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$494/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x11
Self Storage
110 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$353/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x10
Self Storage
100 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$430/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x10
Self Storage
100 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$328/mo
Medium Storage Unit
8x20
Self Storage
160 Sq. Ft.
$492/mo
Medium Storage Unit
5x20
Self Storage
100 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$328/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x13
Self Storage
260 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$1,016/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x11
Self Storage
220 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$812/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x10
Self Storage
200 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$739/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x25
Self Storage
250 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$985/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x20
Self Storage
200 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$739/mo

Amenities

  • Climate-Controlled
  • Indoor
  • 24 hour access
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Retail Available
  • Onsite Manager
  • Contactless Renting
  • Security Camera
  • Elevators
  • Multi-Level Storage
  • Online Payment

What customers are saying

4.8/5 - 462 Reviews

Read some helpful reviews of Extra Space Storage at 1249 Coney Island Avenue, shared by real renters with genuine experiences and honest opinions.

Amazing!!! It’s secure; giving you a sense of relief about your property.Clean spaces and the environment in their gives you that fresh sense also. GREAT Customer Service. Very professional and knowledgeable and interested to make sure your expo is a good one. Service with a Smile. ... Read more
Melita F. - 21 September 2025
NEVER, have I EVER rated a company twice in one day. My first rating of Five ??s went to the location on Empire for their great customer service. They even pointed me in the direction of a location closer to my house. When I arrived on Coney Island Avenue, it was like they rolled out the Red Carpet. The gentleman, whose name I forgot to get, was professional, friendly, and accommodating. His wonderful disposition was a blessing. I sincerely hope someone reads these and rewards them all for going the extra mile to serve the community with excellence and have this customer feeling like the sun is out to shine on her with an added hug from above. 5 ??s All Aroound! ... Read more
Cartrese C. - 31 August 2025
Camille and her co-worker whose name I think is Evelyn were absolutely amazing to work with. They were very respectful and courteous. Extremely efficient and to the point while still being friendly. They deserve a lot more credit than just a review. They are the reason this facility looks and runs as great as it does. I recommend this place to anyone seeking storage. ... Read more
Leonard - 20 August 2025
Whitney S. - 6 August 2025
I want to sincerely thank Camila for her kindness and professionalism! I just rented a storage unit, and she was incredibly helpful and welcoming. She explained everything clearly, answered all my questions, and made the whole process smooth and easy. I truly appreciate her support — it’s always a pleasure to meet someone so attentive and thoughtful. Thank you, Camila! ... Read more
Raysa P. - 18 July 2025
This place is great! Conveniently located, clean and secure. Whenever I have storage needs, I wouldn't even think of going anywhere but here. Carlos and Justine, in particular, are extremely helpful and a real asset to this organization. I have, and will continue, to recommend this place to my friends and everone! ... Read more
Chris M. - 30 June 2025
i was one of the first tenants in this facility when it first opened, when it was still life storage. it has went severely downhill as the years went on. theres always at least 1 miserable nasty employee “working”. sitting on their phone for most of the day and then act like its the biggest inconvenience in the world to do literally anything part of their job description. bring back eglon! he probably left so he wouldn’t have to deal with the nastyness either. the access hours went from 24/7 to 12 hours. the price keeps going up significantly. there’s flooding issues in the lower levels. some of the tenants are questionable, i’ve seen multiple drug addicts passed out in there. ... Read more
K K. - 21 February 2025
I rented a 10x10 storage unit for more than 7 months and was able to access my belongings during the facility's hours of operation; I never encountered any issues or had security concerns, and my most valuable possessions were kept safe and secure, giving me peace of mind. During my move-out day, I met Camille, who offered outstanding support and displayed remarkable friendliness. Her assistance catered to my needs, making the exit process very easy. Located in a desirable area, this facility ensures seamless accessibility. Totally worth the storage space. ... Read more
Delfia B. - 19 January 2025
I have been a loyal customer to lifestorage since the pandemic. In the span of 3 years I went from paying 80/mo to 200/mo. the rent for my unit went from 70$ to 167$, the insurance went from 12$ to 26$, and it went from 24/7 access to 12hr access. All while they've build another facility 2 blocks away from me, they must be making so much money! There are no promotions, gifts, discounts, ANYTHING, for loyal customers. Just increases and greed. I'm so happy that my 200$ a month contributed to them building a second location within a mile radius, maybe the rent will go back down now that that building is up and running. ... Read more
SAINT J. - 9 November 2024
Marcel C. - 17 September 2024
First time renting storage space and I had an extremely pleasant experience thanks to Milana. All my concerns were addressed. Awesome customer service. Highly recommended. Secure place. Free parking available to unload/load. ... Read more
Touqeer A. - 19 August 2024

Storage units in nearby cities

Here is how Brooklyn, NY, compares to other nearby cities. Overall, there are many other great self storage opportunities in the area. Jersey City, NJ, is just 9 miles away and has 10 storage facilities. Monthly rents there start at $9. However, you could also drive to Hoboken, NJ, which is 9 miles away and which also offers storage units for as little as $56. Bayonne, NJ is also just 9 miles distant. Listings there show no less than 2 facilities, with unit prices starting from $27. Looking a bit further away, storage facilities in Union City, NJ, and North Bergen, NJ, have multiple types of units available, with monthly costs starting at $58 and $24, respectively.

Storage units in Jersey City, NJ Within a 9-mile radius
10 Facilities
From $9/mo
Storage units in Hoboken, NJ Within a 9-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $56/mo
Storage units in Bayonne, NJ Within a 9-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $27/mo
Storage units in Union City, NJ Within a 10-mile radius
1 Facility
From $58/mo
Storage units in North Bergen, NJ Within a 11-mile radius
5 Facilities
From $24/mo
Storage units in Secaucus, NJ Within a 12-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $29/mo
Storage units in Kearny, NJ Within a 12-mile radius
1 Facility
From $32/mo
Storage units in Edgewater, NJ Within a 13-mile radius
1 Facility
From $76/mo
Storage units in Lawrence, NY Within a 13-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $9/mo
Storage units in Harrison, NJ Within a 13-mile radius
1 Facility
From $40/mo
Storage units in Elizabeth, NJ Within a 13-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $39/mo
Storage units in Valley Stream, NY Within a 13-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $25/mo
Storage units in Newark, NJ Within a 14-mile radius
12 Facilities
From $6/mo
Storage units in Ridgefield, NJ Within a 14-mile radius
1 Facility
From $18/mo
Storage units in Lyndhurst, NJ Within a 14-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $15/mo
Storage units in North Arlington, NJ Within a 14-mile radius
1 Facility
From $32/mo
Storage units in East Rutherford, NJ Within a 14-mile radius
1 Facility
From $46/mo
Storage units in Fort Lee, NJ Within a 15-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $58/mo
Storage units in Lynbrook, NY Within a 15-mile radius
1 Facility
From $100/mo
Storage units in Little Ferry, NJ Within a 15-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $19/mo

Check out storage units in trending cities

If you want to see how your city compares to others, you can start by checking out other facilities in trending cities. A wide array of storage units can be leased in New York City, NY, Queens, NY and Manhattan, NY, where sizes and amenities may vary. Monthly rents for units in these cities are as low as $5, $9 and $11, respectively.

Storage units in New York City, NY
212 Facilities
From $5/mo
Storage units in Queens, NY
52 Facilities
From $9/mo
Storage units in Manhattan, NY
40 Facilities
From $11/mo
Storage units in Bronx, NY
40 Facilities
From $7/mo
Storage units in Buffalo, NY
7 Facilities
From $23/mo
Storage units in Yonkers, NY
9 Facilities
From $9/mo
Storage units in Rochester, NY
15 Facilities
From $30/mo
Storage units in Syracuse, NY
7 Facilities
From $39/mo
Storage units in Albany, NY
2 Facilities
From $30/mo
Storage units in Hempstead, NY
3 Facilities
From $56/mo
Storage units in Troy, NY
4 Facilities
From $19/mo
Storage units in Penfield, NY
2 Facilities
From $64/mo
Storage units in West Seneca, NY
4 Facilities
From $25/mo
Storage units in Hicksville, NY
5 Facilities
From $19/mo
Browse storage units in all New York cities.

Frequently Asked Questions

Storage units available at Extra Space Storage - 1249 Coney Island Avenue include the following amenities: Climate-Controlled, Indoor, 24 hour access, Drive-Up Access, Retail Available, Onsite Manager, Contactless Renting, Security Camera, Elevators, Multi-Level Storage and Online Payment. Depending on what you need to put away in storage, you can discover there are some things you absolutely need, so make sure you check with the facility manager that you'll find everything you need on site.

This particular storage facility provides self storage units of different sizes, ranging from 20 to 260 square feet. Space is not an issue! If you have more belongings to store, or simply bulkier items or even vehicles, you should go for larger storage units.

You already know how much stuff you need to put in self storage, so figuring out the unit size you need is the next step. Smaller units such as 5'x5' or 5'x10' spaces can usually be filled with the amount of items you would normally store in a closet: a few chairs and lamps, sports equipment, garden tools and some boxes.

Moving on to larger sizes, imagine the 10'x10' and 10'x15' units as similar to a bedroom or a living room – larger pieces of furniture, sturdier equipment and bicycles can fit here. Finally, a 10'x20' unit has enough space for the contents of a 3-bedroom house, while the larger 10'x30' space easily accommodates the contents of a loaded semi-truck.

Monthly prices for units offered by Extra Space Storage - 1249 Coney Island Avenue start from $30 and can go up to $1,016 for larger spaces.

Accessibility and quickness are key when it comes to storage, so drive-up storage units are generally regarded as very convenient. Pull your car right up to your storage space, load, unload, and you're good to go! However, if you're mostly storing temperature-sensitive items, you should rather consider indoor storage units.

Climate-controlled units maintain consistent temperatures and humidity levels all year round, making them perfect for all your sensitive items. Moisture and varying temperatures can damage a whole host of things, and that is why a lot of people choose to use climate-controlled units to store items like wooden furniture, electronics, artwork, documents and photographs, collectibles, antiques, etc. If the belongings you're storing are important to you, you should consider renting a climate-controlled unit.