Apartments for rent – RentCafe
Contact this property now:

Extra Space Storage - 24 Sterling Place, Amityville, NY

Self Storage, Car Storage, RV Storage 20 - 375 Sq. Ft.
4.9/5 - 516 Reviews
Location:
24 Sterling Place, Amityville, NY 11701
All units
Small
Medium
Large
Parking
Loading... Loading results...
Units Availability
Small Storage Unit
10x7
Self Storage
70 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$170/mo
Small Storage Unit
10x6
Self Storage
60 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$153/mo
Small Storage Unit
10x5
Self Storage
50 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$161/mo
Small Storage Unit
10x5
Self Storage
50 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$131/mo
Small Storage Unit
9x10
Self Storage
90 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$216/mo
Small Storage Unit
8x10
Self Storage
80 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$191/mo
Small Storage Unit
8x5
Self Storage
40 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$108/mo
Small Storage Unit
7x10
Self Storage
70 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$170/mo
Small Storage Unit
6x5
Self Storage
30 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$108/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x15
Self Storage
75 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$212/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x15
Self Storage
75 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$181/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x10
Self Storage
50 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$161/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x10
Self Storage
50 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$131/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x7
Self Storage
35 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$96/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x5
Self Storage
25 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$93/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x5
Self Storage
25 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$68/mo
Small Storage Unit
4x5
Self Storage
20 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$55/mo
Medium Storage Unit
15x10
Self Storage
150 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$338/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x15
Self Storage
150 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$364/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x15
Self Storage
150 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$338/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x14
Self Storage
140 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$316/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x12
Self Storage
120 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$273/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x10
Self Storage
100 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$272/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x10
Self Storage
100 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$183 - $241/mo
Medium Storage Unit
9x20
Self Storage
180 Sq. Ft.
$417/mo
Medium Storage Unit
9x15
Self Storage
135 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$308/mo
Medium Storage Unit
8x15
Self Storage
120 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$269/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x15
Self Storage
300 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$769/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x10
Self Storage
200 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$476/mo
Large Storage Unit
15x25
Parking
375 Sq. Ft.
Drive-up Access
Parking
RV Storage
$721/mo
Large Storage Unit
15x20
Parking
300 Sq. Ft.
Drive-up Access
Parking
RV Storage
$589/mo
Large Storage Unit
15x15
Self Storage
225 Sq. Ft.
$460/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x25
Self Storage
250 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$576/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x20
Self Storage
200 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$479/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x20
Self Storage
200 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$476/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x20
Parking
200 Sq. Ft.
Car Storage
Drive-up Access
Parking
$419/mo

Amenities

  • Climate-Controlled
  • Indoor
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Retail Available
  • Onsite Manager
  • Contactless Renting
  • Security Camera
  • Gate
  • Parking
  • Credit Cards Accepted
  • Elevators
  • Multi-Level Storage
  • Online Payment
  • RV Storage

What customers are saying

4.9/5 - 516 Reviews

Read some helpful reviews of Extra Space Storage at 24 Sterling Place, shared by real renters with genuine experiences and honest opinions.

I went into this establishment not knowing what to expect. The facility was very clean and organized. The staff was extremely friendly. Ashley went above and beyond to explain what I needed and what was best for my situation. She was very informative and professional. Super friendly, which was much appreciated. I recommend this location for your storage needs. If you want great customer service, ask for Ashley. ... Read more
Vannie J. - 30 January 2026
Wonderful storage facility! Everything is clean, safe, and easy to access. The staff is amazing — always friendly, helpful, and they truly care about their customers. It’s a pleasure doing business with them. Highly recommend! ... Read more
Olena K. - 8 October 2025
I rented storage space and Extra Space Storage in Amityville, NY for four years. My contents were safe and in the same condition as they were when I initially moved them in. The customer service of the staff was always professional. I’m happy to recommend this service and location to others. ... Read more
William R. - 23 September 2025
Michael (. - 16 September 2025
So disappointed with my experience here, I set myself up online for a 5x5 unit at $55, standard pricing in the area after sometime my rent crept up to $75, I wasn't happy but I understood that it could go up I just got a notice that now pricing is going to be $90 monthly which is outrageous for a 5x5 I called and they offered a $5 discount, for a good i looked how much they charge for a new customer, $53.... So they tell you a price, and keep creeping up the costs because its a hassle to move ones stuff, Staff was nice on the phone bust said this is "an industry practice" a 100% price increase is not correct, this is what you get for being a loyal customer to this company. I will not be taken advantage of and this will be my last month ... Read more
Bill V. - 2 September 2025
Everyone is friendly, personable and accommodating. Switched from a larger unit to a smaller one and the whole process was smooth and fast. Ryan and Ashley were awesome! Would definitely recommend the Amityville location to everyone! ... Read more
Doreen H. - 1 September 2025
Kristine K. - 6 August 2025
Barbara M. - 2 August 2025
Ashley D. - 26 July 2025
My name is Power Richardson, a up and coming entrepreneur trying to make his small business go from dreamscape to landscape. I have had many ups and even more downs trying to get this business off the ground, but I can say with full confidence that Extra Space storage in Amityville is going to be part of my empire. There are not enough words in the English language to describe how good Brianna at Extra Space treated me. I commend her for answering any and all questions I had regarding the purchase and usage of boxes. Even my own patience was running thin with myself, but she encouraged me to go on unlike any other storage employee i have ever encountered. The only thing I’m looking forward to more than paying my rent on time is seeing Brianna again. Thank you Extra Space Amityville. You made me feel much more at home than the SNAKES ?? at Omega storage. DO NOT RENT FROM OMEGA. THEY ARE VIPERS. THANK YOU BRIANNA. ... Read more
Power P. - 25 July 2025
Great experience! Excellent customer service. Everything went smoothly from start to finish. All my questions and concerns were addressed in a friendly and knowledgeable by staff. Working with Veronica was a pleasure. ... Read more
gina s. - 11 February 2025
It’s been a very good experience in the one year; and five months that I have had my stuff in this facility and no hiccups on how to deal with the storage. Thank you to Veronica for helping me with the lock, she was extremely patient and valuable toward me as I needed help with it. ... Read more
Jef - 6 February 2025
I had a great experience with Extra Space storage & I want to give a special shoutout to Veronica for her outstanding service! She was incredibly helpful & knowledgeable throughout the entire process. I highly recommend Extra Space storage, especially if you have the pleasure of working with Veronica! ... Read more
Tricia D. - 17 January 2025
Veronica was outstanding. It was my first time using a storage unit and she took the time to walk me through options and how it all works. They customer service here is just amazing. All the workers are so welcoming and nice. ... Read more
Julia M. - 16 January 2025
I had a very good experience renting a storage unit. Ashley was very thorough in explaining all the information that I needed to know. She also made sure I understood everything in the contract before signing. I highly recommend Extra Space in Amityville. ... Read more
Salexandra R. - 30 November 2024

Storage units in nearby cities

Here is how Amityville, NY, compares to other nearby cities. Overall, there are many other great self storage opportunities in the area. Lindenhurst, NY, is just 3 miles away and has 3 storage facilities. Monthly rents there start at $54. However, you could also drive to Massapequa, NY, which is 3 miles away and which also offers storage units for as little as $25. Famingdale, NY is also just 4 miles distant. Listings there show no less than 4 facilities, with unit prices starting from $31. Looking a bit further away, storage facilities in West Babylon, NY, and Bethpage, NY, have multiple types of units available, with monthly costs starting at $82 and $49, respectively.

Storage units in Lindenhurst, NY Within a 3-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $54/mo
Storage units in Massapequa, NY Within a 3-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $25/mo
Storage units in Famingdale, NY Within a 4-mile radius
4 Facilities
From $31/mo
Storage units in West Babylon, NY Within a 4-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $82/mo
Storage units in Bethpage, NY Within a 6-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $49/mo
Storage units in West Islip, NY Within a 7-mile radius
1 Facility
From $115/mo
Storage units in Melville, NY Within a 7-mile radius
1 Facility
From $67/mo
Storage units in Deer Park, NY Within a 8-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $64/mo
Storage units in Plainview, NY Within a 8-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $32/mo
Storage units in Hicksville, NY Within a 8-mile radius
5 Facilities
From $19/mo
Storage units in Bay Shore, NY Within a 9-mile radius
5 Facilities
From $10/mo
Storage units in Syosset, NY Within a 11-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $40/mo
Storage units in Brentwood, NY Within a 11-mile radius
1 Facility
From $49/mo
Storage units in Huntington Station, NY Within a 11-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $57/mo
Storage units in Rockville Centre, NY Within a 12-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $68/mo
Storage units in West Hempstead, NY Within a 13-mile radius
1 Facility
From $55/mo
Storage units in Commack, NY Within a 13-mile radius
1 Facility
From $46/mo
Storage units in East Northport, NY Within a 14-mile radius
1 Facility
From $54/mo
Storage units in East Rockaway, NY Within a 14-mile radius
1 Facility
From $25/mo
Storage units in Lynbrook, NY Within a 14-mile radius
1 Facility
From $100/mo

Check out storage units in trending cities

If you want to see how your city compares to others, you can start by checking out other facilities in trending cities. A wide array of storage units can be leased in New York City, NY, Brooklyn, NY and Queens, NY, where sizes and amenities may vary. Monthly rents for units in these cities are as low as $5 and $9, respectively.

Storage units in New York City, NY
212 Facilities
From $5/mo
Storage units in Brooklyn, NY
61 Facilities
From $5/mo
Storage units in Queens, NY
52 Facilities
From $9/mo
Storage units in Manhattan, NY
40 Facilities
From $11/mo
Storage units in Bronx, NY
40 Facilities
From $7/mo
Storage units in Buffalo, NY
7 Facilities
From $23/mo
Storage units in Yonkers, NY
9 Facilities
From $9/mo
Storage units in Rochester, NY
15 Facilities
From $30/mo
Storage units in Syracuse, NY
7 Facilities
From $39/mo
Storage units in Albany, NY
2 Facilities
From $30/mo
Storage units in Hempstead, NY
3 Facilities
From $56/mo
Storage units in Troy, NY
4 Facilities
From $19/mo
Storage units in Penfield, NY
2 Facilities
From $64/mo
Storage units in West Seneca, NY
4 Facilities
From $25/mo
Browse storage units in all New York cities.

Frequently Asked Questions

Storage units available at Extra Space Storage - 24 Sterling Place include the following amenities: Climate-Controlled, Indoor, Drive-Up Access, Retail Available, Onsite Manager, Contactless Renting, Security Camera, Gate, Parking, Credit Cards Accepted, Elevators, Multi-Level Storage, Online Payment and RV Storage. Depending on what you need to put away in storage, you can discover there are some things you absolutely need, so make sure you check with the facility manager that you'll find everything you need on site.

This particular storage facility provides self storage units of different sizes, ranging from 20 to 375 square feet. Space is not an issue! If you have more belongings to store, or simply bulkier items or even vehicles, you should go for larger storage units.

You already know how much stuff you need to put in self storage, so figuring out the unit size you need is the next step. Smaller units such as 5'x5' or 5'x10' spaces can usually be filled with the amount of items you would normally store in a closet: a few chairs and lamps, sports equipment, garden tools and some boxes.

Moving on to larger sizes, imagine the 10'x10' and 10'x15' units as similar to a bedroom or a living room – larger pieces of furniture, sturdier equipment and bicycles can fit here. Finally, a 10'x20' unit has enough space for the contents of a 3-bedroom house, while the larger 10'x30' space easily accommodates the contents of a loaded semi-truck.

Monthly prices for units offered by Extra Space Storage - 24 Sterling Place start from $53 and can go up to $694 for larger spaces.

Accessibility and quickness are key when it comes to storage, so drive-up storage units are generally regarded as very convenient. Pull your car right up to your storage space, load, unload, and you're good to go! However, if you're mostly storing temperature-sensitive items, you should rather consider indoor storage units.

Climate-controlled units maintain consistent temperatures and humidity levels all year round, making them perfect for all your sensitive items. Moisture and varying temperatures can damage a whole host of things, and that is why a lot of people choose to use climate-controlled units to store items like wooden furniture, electronics, artwork, documents and photographs, collectibles, antiques, etc. If the belongings you're storing are important to you, you should consider renting a climate-controlled unit.