Apartments for rent – RentCafe
Contact this property now:

Extra Space Storage - 8840 East 42nd Street, Indianapolis, IN

Self Storage, Car Storage, RV Storage 25 - 450 Sq. Ft.
4.8/5 - 374 Reviews
Location:
8840 East 42nd Street, Indianapolis, IN 46226
All units
Small
Medium
Large
Parking
Loading... Loading results...
Units Availability
Small Storage Unit
8x10
Self Storage
80 Sq. Ft.
$88/mo
Small Storage Unit
8x10
Self Storage
80 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$83/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x15
Self Storage
75 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$131/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x15
Self Storage
75 Sq. Ft.
$87/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x10
Self Storage
50 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$113/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x10
Self Storage
50 Sq. Ft.
$84/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x10
Self Storage
50 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$71/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x5
Self Storage
25 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$79/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x5
Self Storage
25 Sq. Ft.
$63/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x5
Self Storage
25 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$53/mo
Small Storage Unit
4x8
Self Storage
32 Sq. Ft.
$120/mo
Medium Storage Unit
16x10
Self Storage
160 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$117/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x15
Self Storage
150 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$182/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x15
Self Storage
150 Sq. Ft.
$118 - $164/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x15
Self Storage
150 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$110/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x10
Self Storage
100 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$153/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x10
Self Storage
100 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$92/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x10
Self Storage
100 Sq. Ft.
$88 - $133/mo
Medium Storage Unit
8x20
Parking
160 Sq. Ft.
Car Storage
Parking
$146/mo
Medium Storage Unit
8x20
Self Storage
160 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$117/mo
Medium Storage Unit
8x15
Self Storage
120 Sq. Ft.
$105/mo
Medium Storage Unit
5x20
Self Storage
100 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$153/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x15
Self Storage
300 Sq. Ft.
$320/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x15
Self Storage
300 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$248/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x10
Self Storage
200 Sq. Ft.
$211/mo
Large Storage Unit
15x30
Parking
450 Sq. Ft.
Drive-up Access
Parking
RV Storage
$373/mo
Large Storage Unit
15x15
Self Storage
225 Sq. Ft.
$283/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x30
Self Storage
300 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$346/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x30
Self Storage
300 Sq. Ft.
$320/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x30
Parking
300 Sq. Ft.
Drive-up Access
Parking
RV Storage
$320/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x30
Self Storage
300 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$248/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x25
Parking
250 Sq. Ft.
Drive-up Access
Parking
RV Storage
$295/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x20
Parking
200 Sq. Ft.
Car Storage
Drive-up Access
Parking
$257/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x20
Self Storage
200 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
$251/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x20
Self Storage
200 Sq. Ft.
Climate-Controlled
Elevator
$208/mo
Large Storage Unit
8x30
Self Storage
240 Sq. Ft.
$290/mo

Amenities

  • Climate-Controlled
  • Indoor
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Retail Available
  • Onsite Manager
  • Contactless Renting
  • Security Camera
  • Gate
  • Parking
  • Enclosed
  • Elevators
  • Multi-Level Storage
  • Online Payment
  • RV Storage

What customers are saying

4.8/5 - 374 Reviews

Read some helpful reviews of Extra Space Storage at 8840 East 42nd Street, shared by real renters with genuine experiences and honest opinions.

Miracles E. - 1 March 2026
Alisha was fantastic from the very beginning to the very end. She was more than willing to show me multiple units without hesitation, and even answered all my what I'm sure were silly questions with a smile! Thank you! ... Read more
Josh B. - 28 February 2026
The staff was very generous, helpful, and friendly. I look forward to keeping my items in their units and doing business with them in the future. The building is very secure with great affordable prices for your money's worth! ... Read more
John B. - 18 December 2025
A few weeks ago, I rented a storage unit from Extra Space Storage, and I was truly blessed to have Fabian assist me through the process. In today’s world, genuine customer service is rare—but Fabian is a gem! She is naturally pleasant, incredibly helpful, and clearly dedicated to her work. I’m giving the highest possible rating because she is worth every single ?? ... Read more
Rochelle H. - 19 September 2025
Whats the point of renting a drive up storage place if you can never drive up to it due to people parking and blocking your unit. Also theres a mice problem check out this gift ?? i have to trash majority of my things ... Read more
Samara R. - 18 September 2025
D K. - 17 September 2025
Samara R. - 30 August 2025
Rent for a 10'x10' went from ~$60 a month to $100 without warning or communication of the increase. Spoke to a rep with this company and I was told that "Extra Space Storage can/will change your rent whenever the market reflects a need to increase"...basically saying that they will charge whatever they feel like and it's up to me to pay to find a new location. Be warned that this company also doesn't cover theft if their employees rob your unit. Happened to my parents at a different location and the company said tough luck. Went through insurance to cover what was stolen but extra space was obstinate through the entire process. ... Read more
Ryan B. - 30 July 2025
So appreciative of the patience Alysha and Leroy showed me today. I lost my keys; and they went above and beyond to get the old lock removed and get me a new one. The atmosphere is welcoming, and so clean!!! If you want people that care, will make you laugh, and get the job done this is the storage place for you! ... Read more
Margret S. - 14 June 2025
China S. - 14 June 2025
Alysha was very helpful today 4/29 As soon as we walked in she greeted us with a big smile and positive attitude. Walked us to the storage units and helped us decide which was more convenient for us! So glad we stopped in today! ... Read more
Jazlyn J. - 29 April 2025
Paul S. - 28 February 2025
Tyler goes above and beyond each time. Thank you ! Update- All managers are always so helpful and knowledgeable. They can’t control rates or increases but they always ensure you get the best deal for your needs. I’ve enjoyed both the unit and office spaces and will always go to Extra Space for my storage needs ... Read more
Ty'Azsha R. - 27 February 2025
Had many bad interactions here but recently had the pleasure of being assisted by Leroy. Amazing customer service, deserves a pay raise. He is the most pleasurable employee working there that I have personally dealt with. Keep him, I will be keeping my business here as long as he is here. 10/10 ... Read more
zayna e. - 23 November 2024
Overall it’s easy to rent a space. But, this particular location wasn’t really up to par. It seemed like no one cleaned it, there was always trash or people’s old belongings sitting out. And my things started to rust a bit and grow mold because the air circulation wasn’t that well. The Manager however was quick to respond to my concerns so I do appreciate that. I did move out but would try a different location if I ever need a unit again. ... Read more
Destiny W. - 31 October 2024
I am pretty impressed with the location, and I was really grateful & thankful for the help, patience service, and awesome customer service Ms.Ty Ridner provided. People often leave bad reviews, but a positive review was warranted. She literally did an amazing job helping us during this stressful transition. ... Read more
clarence w. - 16 December 2023

Nearby Storage Units

Storage units in nearby cities

Here is how Indianapolis, IN, compares to other nearby cities. Overall, there are many other great self storage opportunities in the area. Beech Grove, IN, is just 6 miles away and has 2 storage facilities. Monthly rents there start at $20. However, you could also drive to Speedway, IN, which is 6 miles away and which also offers storage units for as little as $21. Southport, IN is also just 9 miles distant. Listings there show 1 facility, with unit prices starting from $30. Looking a bit further away, storage facilities in New Palestine, IN, and Avon, IN, have multiple types of units available, with monthly costs starting at $43 and $12, respectively.

Storage units in Beech Grove, IN Within a 6-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $20/mo
Storage units in Speedway, IN Within a 6-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $21/mo
Storage units in Southport, IN Within a 9-mile radius
1 Facility
From $30/mo
Storage units in New Palestine, IN Within a 14-mile radius
4 Facilities
From $43/mo
Storage units in Avon, IN Within a 14-mile radius
6 Facilities
From $12/mo
Storage units in Brownsburg, IN Within a 15-mile radius
9 Facilities
From $27/mo
Storage units in McCordsville, IN Within a 15-mile radius
1 Facility
From $79/mo
Storage units in Plainfield, IN Within a 15-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $57/mo
Storage units in Whiteland, IN Within a 16-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $49/mo
Storage units in Zionsville, IN Within a 16-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $16/mo
Storage units in Mooresville, IN Within a 19-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $60/mo
Storage units in Pittsboro, IN Within a 19-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $60/mo
Storage units in Greenfield, IN Within a 20-mile radius
9 Facilities
From $50/mo
Storage units in Whitestown, IN Within a 20-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $22/mo
Storage units in Danville, IN Within a 22-mile radius
7 Facilities
From $49/mo
Storage units in Franklin, IN Within a 23-mile radius
8 Facilities
From $35/mo
Storage units in Clayton, IN Within a 23-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $82/mo
Storage units in Cicero, IN Within a 25-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $50/mo
Storage units in Lebanon, IN Within a 25-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $55/mo
Storage units in Pendleton, IN Within a 25-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $44/mo

Check out storage units in trending cities

If you want to see how your city compares to others, you can start by checking out other facilities in trending cities. A wide array of storage units can be leased in Fort Wayne, IN, South Bend, IN and Fishers, IN, where sizes and amenities may vary. Monthly rents for units in these cities are as low as $15 and $20, respectively.

Storage units in Fort Wayne, IN
30 Facilities
From $15/mo
Storage units in South Bend, IN
11 Facilities
From $20/mo
Storage units in Fishers, IN
8 Facilities
From $20/mo
Storage units in Carmel, IN
8 Facilities
From $49/mo
Storage units in Bloomington, IN
10 Facilities
From $30/mo
Storage units in Hammond, IN
6 Facilities
From $28/mo
Storage units in Noblesville, IN
14 Facilities
From $21/mo
Storage units in Lafayette, IN
17 Facilities
From $10/mo
Storage units in Gary, IN
2 Facilities
From $37/mo
Storage units in Greenwood, IN
7 Facilities
From $20/mo
Storage units in Muncie, IN
14 Facilities
From $15/mo
Storage units in Anderson, IN
12 Facilities
From $25/mo
Storage units in Westfield, IN
3 Facilities
From $55/mo
Storage units in Elkhart, IN
11 Facilities
From $20/mo
Storage units in Mishawaka, IN
14 Facilities
From $18/mo
Storage units in Lawrence, IN
7 Facilities
From $28/mo
Storage units in New Albany, IN
11 Facilities
From $21/mo
Browse storage units in all Indiana cities.

Frequently Asked Questions

Storage units available at Extra Space Storage - 8840 East 42nd Street include the following amenities: Climate-Controlled, Indoor, Drive-Up Access, Retail Available, Onsite Manager, Contactless Renting, Security Camera, Gate, Parking, Enclosed, Elevators, Multi-Level Storage, Online Payment and RV Storage. Depending on what you need to put away in storage, you can discover there are some things you absolutely need, so make sure you check with the facility manager that you'll find everything you need on site.

This particular storage facility provides self storage units of different sizes, ranging from 25 to 450 square feet. Space is not an issue! If you have more belongings to store, or simply bulkier items or even vehicles, you should go for larger storage units.

You already know how much stuff you need to put in self storage, so figuring out the unit size you need is the next step. Smaller units such as 5'x5' or 5'x10' spaces can usually be filled with the amount of items you would normally store in a closet: a few chairs and lamps, sports equipment, garden tools and some boxes.

Moving on to larger sizes, imagine the 10'x10' and 10'x15' units as similar to a bedroom or a living room – larger pieces of furniture, sturdier equipment and bicycles can fit here. Finally, a 10'x20' unit has enough space for the contents of a 3-bedroom house, while the larger 10'x30' space easily accommodates the contents of a loaded semi-truck.

Monthly prices for units offered by Extra Space Storage - 8840 East 42nd Street start from $53 and can go up to $373 for larger spaces.

Accessibility and quickness are key when it comes to storage, so drive-up storage units are generally regarded as very convenient. Pull your car right up to your storage space, load, unload, and you're good to go! However, if you're mostly storing temperature-sensitive items, you should rather consider indoor storage units.

Climate-controlled units maintain consistent temperatures and humidity levels all year round, making them perfect for all your sensitive items. Moisture and varying temperatures can damage a whole host of things, and that is why a lot of people choose to use climate-controlled units to store items like wooden furniture, electronics, artwork, documents and photographs, collectibles, antiques, etc. If the belongings you're storing are important to you, you should consider renting a climate-controlled unit.