• 2 Beds
  • 1 Bath

Bay Colony Apartments

From $875 per month

189-203 E. Fairmount, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217


2 Bedroom Apartment
Two Bedrooms
  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Bath
$875 Available Now
Available Now
Security deposit: $850 - $875. Application fee: $35. Other fees may apply, please contact the property for details.
Visit Property Website

Apartment Amenities

  • Disposal
  • Extra Storage
  • Gas Range
  • Handrails
  • Hardwood Floors
  • Patio/Balcony
  • Refrigerator
View all apartment amenities

Community Amenities

  • One Parking Spot per Unit
  • Availability 24 Hours
  • Bike Racks
  • Courtyard
  • Laundry Facilities
  • Off Street Parking
  • On-Site Maintenance
  • On-Site Management
  • Public Transportation
  • Recycling
View all community amenities


Ready to see this property in person? Contact the property and ask for a private showing!
  • Apartments in the Community: 100
  • Buildings in the Community: 25
  • Number of Stories: 2 - 3
  • Year Built: 1963


The Bay Colony Apartments & Townhouses comprised of the East and West Complex encompasses three, lovely tree lined, blocks of attractive, well-kept, red-brick, colonial style buildings in a quiet, residential area of Whitefish Bay.
Minutes away from the Lake Michigan, parks, and the Milwaukee River, while being close to the Bayshore Town Center, the shops of Silver Spring Drive.
You have convenient access to all that Whitefish Bay offers. Also nearby is Whitefish Bay Schools,  and a short drive to UW-Milwaukee with direct access to I-43.
Contact us today to schedule your tour of our townhomes and apartments. For more availability check out Bay Colony West, featuring great 2 bedroom townhomes and additional apartments.
Request your own private tour

Ratings and Reviews

How would you rate this property?

Pet Policy

  • Pets are not allowed
Have a question? Send a message now.

Average Utility Costs in Wisconsin


Prices in the Area

This community North Shore Whitefish Bay, WI
2 Beds2 Bedrooms $875 $875 - $2,300 $875
Too many options, too little time? Let the Rental Assistant do the search for you!


189-203 E. Fairmount, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217
Points of interest powered by OpenStreetMap
Calculate commute by driving, cycling or walking, where available.
Commute calculator powered by Walk Score® Travel Time
39 /100
63 /100
Walk Score®: 39, Bike Score®: 63

Transit nearby

  • Port Washington & Lydell 0.80 mi
  • Port Washington & Mohawk 0.82 mi
  • Port Washington & Silver Spring 0.87 mi
  • Port Washington & North Shore 0.89 mi
  • Port Washington & Bayshore Lot 0.97 mi
  • Port Washington & North Shore 0.98 mi
Nearby Transit

Useful places nearby

Childcare and schools nearby

Points of interest powered by OpenStreetMap

Why choose Bay Colony Apartments

If you’re looking for a new home in the Whitefish Bay Neighborhood in Whitefish Bay, WI you’re in luck - the Bay Colony Apartments community has 1 apartment for rent available right now! This community offers amenities such as One Parking Spot per Unit, Availability 24 Hours and Bike Racks, and is located on 189-203 E.
Fairmount in the 53217 zip code.
The 2 Bedroom apartment is equipped with amenities such as Disposal, Extra Storage and Gas Range, and has a rental rate of $875. Check out the 2 Bedroom floorplan and apply for a lease online! The Ogden & Co.
property management company will verify your lease application and send you a timely response. Once you become a resident of Bay Colony Apartments, you will be able to pay your rent online, submit maintenance requests, and get community news by logging in securely to your Resident Portal.
  • Monday-Friday: 9:00AM-5:30PM
Showings by appointment, flexible showing times to fit your schedule. Contact us for details.

Compare with similar properties

No rating yet
No pets
No A/C
No W/D Hookup
$1,370 - $1,975
1-2 BEDS
W/D Hookup
$1,200 - $1,680
No parking
W/D Hookup
No rating yet
$1,070 - $1,325
1-2 BEDS
No parking
No A/C
W/D Hookup

Frequently Asked Questions

The following floorplans are available: 2-bedrooms apartments from $875.

The most popular nearby apartments are: Bay Colony Apartments, Element 84, Latitude and Arbor Ridge Apartments.

Currently, Bay Colony Apartments has 6 available units.

Bay Colony Apartments is located in the Greater Milwaukee neighborhood.

The business hours are:
  • Monday-Friday: 9:00AM-5:30PM