How many units are available?

Currently, Sheffield at Sylvan has 0.

1 / 15

Image of kitchen with cabinets and appliances

2 / 15

3 / 15

4 / 15

Property sign with flowers at Sheffield at Sylvan in Ohio

5 / 15

Property sign at Sheffield at Sylvan in Ohio

New units available

(44)

Base rent $925 - $1,125

Beds 1-2 Beds

Baths 1-1.5

Sheffield At Sylvan

321 Pontious Lane A4, Circleville, OH

Request a tour

Select a date to start scheduling a tour.

Floor plans

Updated today

This listing displays base rent, which is the rent provided by the property and may not include recurring monthly fees and costs. Contact the property for more information. Show more

The Wimbley

1 Bed / 1 Bath / 625 Sqft

$925

Floor plan details

Unit	Base rent	Availability
06-F43	$925	Now	View
10-C22	$925	Now	View

The Berkshire

2 Beds / 1 Bath / 864 Sqft

$1,040

Floor plan details

Unit	Base rent	Availability
12-E30	$1,090	Jul 20	View

The Londoner

2 Beds / 1 Bath / 936 Sqft

$1,050

Floor plan details

Check for available units

The Yorkshire

2 Beds / 1.5 Baths / 936 Sqft

$1,060

Floor plan details

Check for available units

The Oxford

2 Beds / 1.5 Baths / 936 Sqft

$1,100

Floor plan details

Check for available units

The Somerset

2 Beds / 1.5 Baths / 936 Sqft

$1,125

Floor plan details

Check for available units

Policies

Security deposit $262

Application fees $50

There may be additional unit-specific fees. Please select a unit and move-in date here.

One-time pet fees $250

Monthly pet rent $30

Pet limit 2 allowed. Breed Restrictions Apply, Please Inquire. One-time Non-refundable Pet Fee $300 (1 pet) / $500 (2 pets, max) Monthly Pet Fee $35.00 Per Pet

The fees are estimates and actual amounts may vary. Pricing and availability are subject to change. For details, contact the property.

Amenities

Apartment amenities

Cable Ready
Air Conditioner
Carpeting
Ceiling Fan
Dishwasher
Disposal
Efficient Appliances
Furnished
Plank Flooring
High Ceilings
Large Closets
Patio/Balcony
Refrigerator
W/D Hookup
Window Coverings

Community amenities

High Speed Internet
On-Site Maintenance
On-Site Management
Garage
Off Street Parking
Package Receiving
Flexible Security Deposit Program
Short Term Lease

Services

We prioritize your convenience with Renter Essentials that help you move in easily and live comfortably at Sheffield At Sylvan.

Flex rent payments
Renters insurance

Ratings and reviews

3.5 Very good

44 Reviews

What renters are saying

Renters appreciate various positive aspects of the property, including its quiet and peaceful atmosphere, friendly and accommodating staff, and the efficient and responsive maintenance team. Many residents have highlighted the well-maintained landscaping, clean and nice apartment complex, and the spacious units with high ceilings and walk-in closets. The community is described as friendly, with nice neighbors and pet-friendly policies. Additionally, some renters have mentioned the convenience of having a one-car detached garage and the availability of washer/dryer hook-ups. Overall, renters find it a great place to live and would recommend it to others.

Parking 3.5

Amenities 3.0

Maintenance 4.0

Staff 3.5

Value 3.5

Location 4.5

Noise 4.0

Robert K. Verified Resident

Sep 9, 2025

It's a very nice place to live I enjoy calling Sheffield at Sylvan apartments my home :)

Lynn W. Current Resident

Oct 18, 2024

Maintenance take too long before fixing anything and rent is very expensive.

Anonymous Verified Resident

Feb 2, 2024

Fairly quiet. Maintenance is very professional and accommodating. The price is ridiculous! It’s outdated! I have been paying an ‘updated’ charge of 40 dollars per month which includes a new peel n stick floor which ive paid for the last 3 years. If you do the month, thats one expensive floor.

Katherine s. Verified Resident

Jan 17, 2024

Been here 6 years I can't complain wish the heating and air conditioning would get a upgrade

Anonymous Verified Resident

Nov 29, 2023

Never anyone in office or phone calls to main office not returned. Maintenance guy is awesome.as returns calls.immediately.and.fixes problems

Anonymous Verified Resident

Nov 6, 2023

I have always enjoyed living at Sheffield. Maintenance comes right away to repair any item I report.

Building details

19 buildings in the community 136 apartments in the community 1 - 2 stories per building Building constructed in 1989

Property description

All adult applicants over the age of 18 must submit a fully completed, dated and signed rental application and pay a $50 application fee. A $250 nonrefundable admin fee will be charged at the time of move-in.

Request private tour