Save This Search

Houses for Rent in Tolleston, Gary, IN

24 Rentals Available
  • A black couch with a striped pillow sits in a living room with a glass coffee table.
    1 day ago

    4138 W. 20Th Ave., Gary, IN 46404
    3 BEDS $1,550
  • A kitchen with wooden cabinets and a black stove top oven.
    Today

    754 Durbin St, Gary, IN 46406
    2 BEDS $1,425
  • A spacious living room with wood flooring and a staircase leading to the second floor.
    Today

    423 Hayes St, Gary, IN 46404
    3 BEDS $1,650
  • 3326 Delaware Street 3 Beds Apartment for Rent
    1 day ago

    3326 Delaware Street, Gary, IN 46409
    3 BEDS $1,500
  • a kitchen with a sink and a stove and a window
    10
    1 day ago

    2267 Tennessee Street, Gary, IN 46407
    2 BEDS $1,275
  • Renting has its Rewards
    Start earning points to redeem on travel, experiences, gift cards, live events, and more!
    Earn points for:
    Internet and Entertainment
    Utilities
    Insurance
    Learn more
  • A kitchen with brown cabinets and a white dishwasher.
    1 day ago

    3464 Pennsylvania Street, Gary, IN 46409
    3 BEDS $1,495
  • 4340 Buchanan Street 3 Beds Apartment for Rent
    1 day ago

    4340 Buchanan Street, Gary, IN 46408
    3 BEDS $1,300
  • 4381 Johnson Street Studio Apartment for Rent
    Today

    4381 Johnson Street, Gary, IN 46408
  • 4172 Jefferson Street 3 Beds Apartment for Rent
    1 day ago

    4172 Jefferson Street, Gary, IN 46408
    3 BEDS $1,595
  • A kitchen with white cabinets and a black stove top.
    Today

    4667 Massachusetts St, Gary, IN 46409
    2 BEDS $1,425
  • A kitchen with white cabinets and a black countertop.
    Today

    512 W 49Th Ave, Gary, IN 46408
    4 BEDS $2,000
  • Interactive banner rent
    What is your max rent budget?
  • A modern kitchen with stainless steel appliances and wooden flooring.
    Today

    4276 Martin Luther King Drive, Gary, IN 46409
    3 BEDS $1,395
  • 2934 165Th St 3 Beds Apartment for Rent
    1 day ago

    2934 165Th St, Hammond, IN 46320
  • 1024 East 51St Place 4 Beds Apartment for Rent
    Today

    1024 East 51St Place, Gary, IN 46409
    4 BEDS $1,495
  • The image is a logo for McCormick Real Estate.
    1 day ago

    6735 Van Buren Place, Merrillville, IN 46410
    3 BEDS $2,195
  • A living room with a black leather couch and a grey rug.
    Today

    8307 Greenwood Ave, Munster, IN 46321
    2 BEDS $2,400
  • A living room with a large couch and a television.
    Today

    9536 Elmwood Dr, Munster, IN 46321
    5 BEDS $3,550
  • Interactive banner bedroom
    How many bedrooms are you
    looking for?
  • the front of a brick house with a lawn
    1 day ago

    431 W Vine St, Hammond, IN 46327
    3 BEDS $1,750
  • A kitchen with a refrigerator, stove, and sink.
    Today

    325 Fairbanks Pl, Munster, IN 46321
    3 BEDS $2,495
  • A living room with a table and chairs and a ceiling fan.
    Today

    930 North Warrick Street, Gary, IN 46403
    3 BEDS $1,900
  • A kitchen with a black counter top and wooden cabinets.
    Today

    18428 Lange St, Lansing, IL 60438
    3 BEDS $2,285
  • A living room with a grey couch and a television.
    Today

    32 156Th St, Calumet City, IL 60409
    4 BEDS $2,000
  • the wordscanningsoon on a black and white background
    Today

    17053 Grant St, Lansing, IL 60438
    3 BEDS $2,255
  • A kitchen with dark blue cabinets and a white countertop.
    Today

    1621 Magnolia Avenue, Dyer, IN 46311
    1 BED $1,600
  • A spacious room with a ceiling fan and wooden flooring.
    Today

    5625 Burr Ridge Circle, Crown Point, IN 46307
    4 BEDS $3,400
1-24-nhood
Nice work, you've checked out every rental here! Expand your search to find your happy place.

Save Search

Getting around in Tolleston, IN

29 /100
Car-Dependent
31 /100
Somewhat Bikeable
Walk Score®: 29, Bike Score®: 31

Frequently asked questions

How many houses are available in Tolleston, Gary, IN on RentCafe?

There are 1 house rentals available on RentCafe. Prices and availability in Tolleston, Gary, IN were last updated on 19 Nov 2025.

What is the average size of a rental house in Tolleston, Gary, IN?

The average Tolleston, Gary, IN rental house size is 1,081 sq. ft.

What are the advantages of renting a house in Tolleston, Gary, IN?

Renting a house in Tolleston, Gary, IN comes with more space, both indoor and outdoor.

What are the downsides of renting a house apartment in Tolleston, Gary, IN?

Houses for rent in Tolleston, Gary, IN are usually located in non-central areas.

Tolleston, Gary, IN demographics

  • 16,846Total Population
  • 8,909 Female
    7,937 Male
  • 34Median Age

In total, Tolleston, Gary, IN has 16,846 residents, 8,909 women and 7,937 men, per U.S. Census recent estimates. Statistics show that the median age of Tolleston’s population is 34.

Tolleston, Gary, IN households

  • 4,032 Family
    2,168 Non-family
  • 2,107 Children
    4,093 No Children
  • 6,200Total Number of Households
  • 2Average People Per Household
  • $39,188Median Household Income

There is a total of 6,200 households in Tolleston, Gary, IN. Of these, 2,107 have children and 4,093 are without children. Per Census Bureau’s most current estimates, 4,032 family households and 2,168 non-family households live in this area. The size of a household in Tolleston is 2 people, on average. The median household annual income in Tolleston equals $39,188, and the monthly housing costs equal $884.

Tolleston, Gary, IN education statistics

According to data from the U.S. Census Bureau, 2% of the population in Tolleston, Gary, IN have no high school education, 47% went to high-school, and 29% have partially completed college. Moreover, 8% of the population hold an Associate Degree, 10% hold a Bachelor Degree, and 4% hold a Graduate Degree.

Renting a house in Tolleston, Gary, IN

You know it’s time for a change, and snatching your dream house might be the perfect way to start. If you’re not sure where to look, we’ll give you a tip. About 11 rental homes are located in Tolleston, Gary, IN, ranging in price from $1,495 to $3,995. Whether you’re looking for duplexes, townhouses or single family homes for rent, you’re sure to find what you need. The average rent for a Tolleston, Gary, IN property is about $2,531, but if you’re looking for cheap houses for rent, take a look at 1 bedroom and 2 bedroom properties, which are likely to be more affordable.

Renting a house. It’s a family affair!

Single family homes have long been an attractive option for family oriented people. If you have a big family, 3 bedroom and 4 bedroom properties might be the right fit for you. To find the home of your dreams, don’t forget to use the filters on RentCafe, so you can be sure that you’re not wasting any time looking at properties that don’t interest you. Soon enough you will be enjoying the privacy and comfort of your new home, without any noises coming from the upstairs neighbors. Don’t forget about the added benefit of having a backyard, a safe place for your children and family pet, where you can also try your hand at gardening and, why not, grow your own organic vegetables. Don’t forget to ask your landlord for permission in writing before you make any changes to the landscape. If one of the 11 Tolleston, Gary, IN homes for rent is the right one for you, you can apply for a lease online right here on RentCafe.

Finding a home nearby is easier than you think. Check out our Apartments Near Me page and take your pick!