""
Tap here to try the Rental Assistant! ×
Save This Search

Apartments for Rent in Middletown, NY under $2500
12 Rentals Available

  • Top Rated for Location
    Today

    2 Underhill Road, Middletown, NY 10940
    3 Units available
    • 1 BED
    • 2 BEDS
    • 3 BEDS
    • $1,640
    • $2,055
    • Ask for pricing
    View Property
  • Top Rated for Location
    Today

    23 James P Kelly Way, Middletown, NY 10940
    Available
    • 1 BED
    • $2,255+
    View Property
  • Resident Rated
    Today

    50 Cantrell Avenue, Middletown, NY 10940-5400
    3 Units available
    • 1 BED
    • 2 BEDS
    • 3 BEDS
    • $980
    • $1,320
    • Ask for pricing
    View Property
  • Today

    Cambridge, Middletown, NY 10941
    2 Units available
    • 1 BED
    • 2 BEDS
    • $1,500
    • $1,650
    View Property
  • Top Rated for Location
    Today

    225 Berkman Dr, Middletown, NY 10941
    Available
    • Studio
    • 1 BED
    • 2 BEDS
    • Ask for pricing
    • $1,605+
    • $1,980+
    View Property
  • Interactive banner bedroom
    How many bedrooms are you
    looking for?
    • Studio
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • 4+
  • Too many options, too little time? Let the Rental Assistant do the search for you!
  • Today

    131 Rivers Edge Drive, Matamoras, PA 18366
    Income Restricted
    • 1 BED
    • 2 BEDS
    • $830
    • Ask for pricing
    View Property
  • 10 days ago

    19 NEVINS STREET, ELLENVILLE, NY 12428
    1 Unit available
    • 3 BEDS
    • $1,865
    View Property
3-4-city

Popular searches Average rent Renters guide Demographics

Getting around in Middletown, NY

90 /100
Very Walkable
50 /100
Bikeable
Walk Score®: 90, Bike Score®: 50

Renting apartments in Middletown, NY under $2,500

Are you looking for a smart space where you can easily combine comfort with convenience? You will surely find the property that perfectly fits your needs with this variety of options. RentCafe offers you 12 apartments for rent in Middletown, NY from 7 modern buildings, so you’ll certainly find something suitable for you. If you want to live alone or with your partner, you might want to look for a studio or browse through our selection of 1 bedroom apartments. If you need more space but you don’t want to spend more than necessary on a monthly rent, check out our 2 bedroom or 3 bedroom apartments for less than $2,500, and make the most out of your budget.

Finding the best rental near you

Middletown, NY is an amazing place to call home, with several rentals under $2,500 for you to choose from. There are many options and filters you can apply to your search to make the process easier and to find your next apartment faster and more efficiently. Asking yourself ‘are there any cheap apartments near me’? With our helpful filters, you can easily find the home of your dreams that also fits within your budget. With rent prices as low as $830 in Middletown, NY, you can find affordable and appealing apartments that match your requirements. Sort your search by ‘Rent’ ascending to see the cheapest ones at the top of the list. As soon as you find your perfect apartment, make sure to contact the property to check for availability or apply online directly on RentCafe.

Finding a home nearby is easier than you think. Check out our Apartments Near Me page and take your pick!