Tap here to try the Rental Assistant! ×
Save This Search

Apartments for Rent in Fleming Island, FL under $2500
145 Rentals Available

  • 25
    Today

    2285 Marsh Hawk Lane, Fleming Island, FL 32003
    1 BED $1,468+
    2 BEDS $1,658+
    3 BEDS $1,878+
  • Today

    2090 Hawkeye Pl, Fleming Island, FL 32003
    3 BEDS $2,499
  • Today

    2047 Eclipse Dr, Middleburg, FL 32068
    3 BEDS $2,065
  • Today

    534 College Drive, Middleburg, FL 32068
    Income Restricted
    STUDIO $954
    1 BED $1,077
    2 BEDS $1,297
  • 5
    Today

    1810 Dartmouth Dr, Middleburg, FL 32068
    4 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • Renting has its Rewards
    Start earning points to redeem on travel, experiences, gift cards, live events, and more!
    Earn points for:
    Internet and Entertainment
    Utilities
    Insurance
    Learn more
  • Today

    2835 TANGLEWOOD BOULEVARD, ORANGE PARK, FL 32065
    3 BEDS $2,065
  • Today

    1512 PAWNEE ST., ORANGE PARK, FL 32065
    STUDIO $1,400
  • Today

    2261 GEORGE WHYTHE ROAD, ORANGE PARK, FL 32073
    STUDIO $1,100
  • Today

    3422 Traceland Oak Ln, Green Cove Springs, FL 32043
    4 BEDS $2,250
  • 57
    Today

    409 Jefferson Ave, Orange Park, FL 32065
    STUDIO Ask for Pricing
    1 BED Ask for Pricing
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • Today

    1554 Slash Pine Ct, Orange Park, FL 32073
    3 BEDS $2,000
  • Too many options, too little time? Take a quiz and let us do the search for you
  • 29
    Today

    1809 Debarry Avenue, Orange Park, FL 32073
    Income Restricted
    1 BED Call for pricing
    2 BEDS Call for pricing
    3 BEDS Call for pricing
  • 21
    Today

    25 Knight Boxx Road, Orange Park, FL 32065
    1 BED $1,283+
    2 BEDS $1,408+
    3 BEDS $1,523+
  • 13
    Today

    3045 Glen Park Lane, Orange Park, FL 32065
    2 BEDS $1,375
    3 BEDS $1,550
  • 22
    Today

    3045 Glen Park Lane, Orange Park, FL 32065
    1 BED $1,295+
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • Today

    1535 Blanding Blvd., Middleburg, FL 32068
    Income Restricted
    1 BED $928
    2 BEDS $1,122
    3 BEDS $1,305
  • 49
    Today

    198 Arora Boulevard, Orange Park, FL 32073
    1 BED $1,230+
    2 BEDS $1,251+
    3 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • Interactive banner bedroom
    How many bedrooms are you
    looking for?
  • 91
    Today

    1408 N. Orange Ave., Green Cove Springs, FL 32043
    STUDIO Ask for Pricing
    1 BED Ask for Pricing
    2 BEDS $1,115+
  • 1 day ago

    130 Orion Street, Orange Park, FL 32073
    3 BEDS $1,500
  • Today

    3267 Chad Bourne Dr, Green Cove Springs, FL 32043
    4 BEDS $1,875
  • 58
    Today

    1710 Wells Road, Orange Park, FL 32073
    1 BED $999+
    2 BEDS $1,355+
  • 37
    Today

    351 Crossing Blvd, Orange Park, FL 32073
    1 BED $1,250+
    2 BEDS $1,284+
    3 BEDS $1,512+
  • Today

    3854 Falcon Crest Dr, Green Cove Springs, FL 32043
    4 BEDS $2,205
  • Today

    3525 Macie Loop, Middleburg, FL 32068
    Income Restricted
    1 BED $880
    2 BEDS $1,236
  • Today

    2361 Bonnie Lakes Dr, Green Cove Springs, FL 32043
    4 BEDS $2,040
2-23-city
Nice work, you've checked out every rental here! Expand your search to find your happy place.

Save Search
Popular searches Average rent Renters guide Demographics

Getting around in Fleming Island, FL

40 /100
Car-Dependent
33 /100
Somewhat Bikeable
Walk Score®: 40, Bike Score®: 33

Frequently asked questions

When were prices and availability in Fleming Island, FL last updated?

Prices and availability in Fleming Island, FL were last updated on 5 Jul 2025.

What are the best apartments in Fleming Island, FL?

The best apartments in Fleming Island, FL are: MAA Fleming Island, 2305 YELLOW JASMINE LANE FLEMING ISLAND, FL 32003, 1460 Greenway Pl Fleming Island, FL 32003, 2090 Hawkeye Pl and 1672 Misty Lake Dr.

What type of rental buildings are in Fleming Island, FL?

In Fleming Island, 13% of the residents are renting compared to 87% owning a home, according to data from the U.S. Census Bureau. Large-scale apartment buildings with more than 50 units represent 10% of Fleming Island’s rentals, 56% are small-scale complexes with under 50 units, and 34% are single-family rentals.

Renting apartments in Fleming Island, FL under $2,500

Searching for apartments for rent in Fleming Island, FL under $2,500 is not an easy task, but luckily you have come to the right place. Whether you are a student on a budget, a young professional on the move, or simply a frugal person, RentCafe can help you find what you are looking for. Just make sure you know what you consider non-negotiable and what you can compromise on. Your new home is just a few clicks away. In Fleming Island, FL, where the average rent is $1,914 per month, there are 145 units available for less than $2,500. Click on any of these units to see pictures, floor plans, amenities and more. After you have picked your favorite, you can contact the property to check availability. Considering that you are trying to spend as little as possible, looking at 1 bedroom apartments and studio apartments might be a good idea.

We’ll help you find the cheapest rental near you

Finding a nice cheap apartment is by no means impossible. You just have to be patient. Your “apartments near me under $2,500” search can bear fruit sooner than you think if you look carefully and check our site often. You never know when discount deals and special offers might pop up. Keep in mind that you are not the only one looking for an affordable apartment in Fleming Island, FL. Choose “Save Search” to receive the latest apartments available directly to your inbox. This way, you will be able to stay one step ahead of the competition. With the cheapest apartments in Fleming Island, FL going for $880 per month, there are great deals waiting to be discovered. Feeling lucky? Expand your search to 2 bedroom apartments and 3 bedroom apartments as well for more space.

Finding a home nearby is easier than you think. Check out our Apartments Near Me page and take your pick!