""
Save This Search

Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY under $2300
22 Rentals Available


Bay Shore, NY Demographics

  • Total Population29,799
  • Female 15,075
    Male 14,724
  • Median Age35.7

Average Rent in Bay Shore, NY

  • Bay Shore, NY Average Rental Price, October 2021 $1,989 /mo

Bay Shore, NY Apartment Rent Ranges

Bay Shore, NY Rent Trends

Average Rent Jul / 2018 Nov / 2018 Mar / 2019 Jul / 2019 Nov / 2019 Mar / 2020 Jul / 2020 Nov / 2020 Mar / 2021 Oct / 2021
Bay Shore, NY $1,673 $1,715 $1,747 $1,782 $1,789 $1,841 $1,836 $1,821 $1,939 $1,989
National $1,347 $1,356 $1,361 $1,393 $1,400 $1,402 $1,393 $1,397 $1,485 $1,510

Bay Shore, NY Households

  • Total Number of Households8,915
  • Family 6,441
    Non-family 2,474
  • Children 3,705
    No Children 5,210
  • Average People Per Household3.31
  • Median Household Income$80,341
  • Median Housing Costs Per Month$1,955

Bay Shore, NY Education Statistics

Your search for apartments in Bay Shore, NY under $2,300 stops here

Finding apartments for rent in Bay Shore, NY for less than $2,300 has never been so easy! At RENTCafé nice cheap apartments are just one click away. There are currently 22 available units in Bay Shore, NY, renting for under $2,300. On average, $2,007 can get you 711 Sq.Ft. in this area. Be sure to search for the apartment that is best for you. Under “More”, check the amenities that you consider a must-have, and don’t forget to look at the pet policy. Fitness enthusiasts can even check the Fitness Center box. Whether you are looking for studio apartments, 1 bedroom apartments, 2 bedroom apartments or 3 bedroom apartments, you are sure to find one that will make you want to move in right away.

We’ll help you find the best rental near you

Having to compromise on either price or location can turn your “apartments near me under $2,300” search into a nightmare. At RENTCafé we recognize the importance of both. Therefore, we offer a variety of filters that can help you find exactly what you want. Sorting the results by rent, ascending, will make the cheapest units show up first on the list. Try it out! You will find that right now the cheapest apartment under $2,300 in Bay Shore, NY goes for $1,558 per month. If some of the results are outside the area of your choice, you can go to the left side of the screen and draw a radius or a polygon around your location. Now you will only see results that are relevant to you.

Finding a home nearby is easier than you think. Check out our Apartments Near Me page and take your pick!